Theo’s Eatery

Theo's is definitely worth the drive, a Great way to start February. 1st restaurant visit of 2022 and we couldn't have picked a better spot. One order of Souvlaki and one Chicken Parm, each came with choice of salad. Frances our server was excellent! Food is Fantastic

Great restaurant! Service is efficient & friendly. Food is flavourful & portions are generous. Dinning room is nicely decorated & clean. Great for a special occasion or a casual dinner Try the Penne California - it’s delicious. Kid-friendliness: Website doesn’t mention a kids menu, but they do have one. Pizza was a big hit!

First time ever going there! Staff were amazing and super friendly! The food was amazing. Service and timing for everything was 10/10 we forgot our take out boxes and called back for them to hold onto them. And they wrote a sweet little note on the box!

Went here on a Friday night and it was very busy. Should make reservations just to be safe. Waited 20 minutes for a table but I didn't mind. Ordered the Margherita Flatbread for an appetizer. Best Flatbread I've ever had. For dinner my spouse got the chicken Parmigiana sandwich with Cesar salad. I got the chicken and cheese tortellini baked pasta. For all of these meals I can say the vegetables and the bread don't get any fresher that what they were. Soft, juicy, flavourful and delicious. My new favorite spot

Pretty decent quality for the price. Fair value. The menu has some very delicious meals. I chose the chicken. Two breasts and veggies with a side of rice. The veggies were definitely not frozen and the rice was fluffy. The chicken was juicy and just the right portions!

First time here. Made reservations for a late lunch/early before heading to Casino Rama to see Air Supply. I ordered French Onion Soup to start, Chicken Cordon Bleu with roasted red potatoes and Baklava with honey for dessert.

First time at this restaurant recommended by family and now we know why. Highly recommend. Excellent food, very tasty and served hot. Friendly staff. We will definitely come again.

Gorgeous and well maintained venue, hearty portions, great prices, fantastic staff. The wait was going to be over an hour because of a few large reservations and the hostess was kind enough to take our phone number and give us a call when a table freed up and then held it for us until we got back. Overall the bill only came to a bit over $40 for 2 massive dinner entrees and that was with me ordering a Somersby! Definitely coming back next time I'm in Orillia, this place is a gem! The photos are of the massive, football-sized dish of lasagna and a bacon cheeseburger the size of my face with a bowl of fries. The vegetables were flawless and fresh and I could feel the heat radiating off the plates.

While the food was great, it was the service that MADE the experience. Katherine was more than just knowledgeable, friendly, and attentive...she went above & beyond. Our large guest total had changed, and she promptly adjusted the seating without any issue. She addressed each of the children with thoughtful questions, making them feel valued & important. She offered alternative options from the take-out menu when she sensed we had other pizza toppings in mind. She anticipated the need for refills before we asked. She did absolutely everything with a smile and joked with us, making her feel like part of the family dinner experience. After so long abstaining from sit-in dining, we'll go back to Theo's before anywhere else. And if I had a business of my own, I'd try to steal Katherine away from them. She deserves a raise and/or recognition for her effort and generally wonderful presence. I should mention, the steak, stir fry, burger, pasta, and pizza were all absolutely delicious too. Thanks for reminding us what normalcy can feel like, especially with such top-notch service.

Excellent food. Friendly service. Nice restaurant. Highly recommend! We went with two young kids and the staff were great! Good options for vegetarians and quick service.