Pontiac Lodge

We stayed here for one of our trips to the Island and liked the location until the bars let out at 2 am, it was loud. We turned the a/c fan onto higher to create noise to reduce the noise from bar visitors. The prices were good here but watch where your room is located.
8 years ago (09-01-2018)

We rented room 29 here for our friends wedding on the island. It is the only room with no windows but a skylight above the bed. The room was itself was a decent size with a queen bed and a day bed. The day bed had tape around the brackets holding the mattress to the frame. The bathroom fan only worked intermittently. For the same price you could get a room with windows and better upkeep.
8 years ago (20-06-2017)

Decent sized, clean rooms, with nice decor. Cheapest rooms on the island, but not by much. I think we ended up saving about $10-$20 but discovered after we checked in that it's about the only place to stay on the island that doesn't offer any kind of breakfast. Also, there's some sort of place below it that plays MmmchaMmmchaMmchaMmmcha music kind of late that reverberates through the floor. And I've stayed on the island multiple times, but never right downtown Main St. so I didn't even think about the loud drunk yellers, and the draft horse clippity clops all night. Would I stay here again? No. Definitely not. I'll pay the extra $20 and get some peace and quiet and a free breakfast. There's at least 2 other places on the island that have comparable rooms for almost as cheap. Also, in reading another reviewers issues with the office totally closing down after hours I'd be scared to stay again. 😳
8 years ago (24-08-2017)

Great boutique hotel in the middle of the action. Reliable service. Close to everything. We stay here every summer
8 years ago (17-06-2017)

Great place to stay! Beautiful view of the bay and located perfectly in town close to restaurants and shops.
8 years ago (29-07-2017)