facebooktwitterpinterest

Reviews, get directions and information for Old Mexico Restaurant & Cantina

Old Mexico Restaurant & Cantina

About

Hours of Operation
M-Th 11-10
Fri 11-11
Sat 12-11
Sun 12-9

Address: 357 Elmira Rd, Ithaca, NY 14850, USA
Phone: (607) 379-6178
State: New York
County: Tompkins County
Zip Code: 14850


Similar places near
McDonald's McDonald's 130 miles Just so people are aware (I tend to look at reviews for places, but not questions)--t...
Burger King Burger King 141 miles Love the staff. Especially Christin the manager. She has an amazing personality and i...
Arby's Arby's 236 miles Unsure why there was a turtle in the toilet. But the food was decent and every one wa...
Wendy's Wendy's 262 miles Great if you want and order a Caesar salad and leave the takeout window with a salad ...
Denny's Denny's 279 miles Labor day, place is busy. So far so good.... update: what started as a 5star experien...
Moe's Southwest Grill Moe's Southwest Grill 287 miles Best value for your money, for this kind of food, especially on Moe Monday (every Mon...
Chinese Buffet Restaurant Chinese Buffet Restaurant 331 miles When I found the buffet with such a low price, my expectations is not high. But I d...
Dunkin' Donuts Dunkin' Donuts 337 miles Parking is weird. I've ordered the same thing at other Dunkin Donuts many times with ...
Panera Bread Panera Bread 538 miles Panera as a company has great food! This location does carry that, but their service ...
Firehouse Subs Firehouse Subs 580 miles For what could be described as a fast food chain, the customer service here is impecc...
Ling Ling Restaurant Ling Ling Restaurant 1 km Yes, it's American Chinese. No spectacular dishes, but the food is fresh and tasty. S...
Chili's Grill & Bar Chili's Grill & Bar 1 km Food and service is always amazing wait staff is great. Best Corp chain restaurant in...
MIX MIX 1 km This restaurant is really, really good. The tapas portions are far more generous than...
Dunkin' Donuts Dunkin' Donuts 2 km The young man at the counter, was obviously new, but was very polite. Food good, cust...
Jade Garden Restaurants Jade Garden Restaurants 2 km The food is so tasty and freshly made to order. The employees are very nice and frien...
Gimme! Coffee Gimme! Coffee 2 km Hip but welcoming, great espresso drinks with smooth, delious foam. I recommend a moc...
Coltivare Coltivare 2 km We might as well have gone to Golden Corral. I chose Coltivare for our Mother's Day ...
Joe's Restaurant Joe's Restaurant 2 km Waitress was very nice. The food was delicious. I only wish that the people I was wit...
Reviews
Great place with amazing vibes. They serve beautiful hot chips with cold salsa as soon as you enter! Great variety of food. Don't forget to order their margarita pitcher! SO GOOD! Worth every penny. The bigger the group, the better !!
7 years ago (23-09-2017)
I really liked the shrimp Diablo, it was very hot! Be careful. I'm used to a decent amount of heat and I was panting and constantly drinking iced tea after. My girlfriend didn't like that they used American cheese in her dish, and I can't give 5 stars to a Mexican restaurant that uses American cheese. If it were not for that I would though. I liked the atmosphere and the music and the service.
7 years ago (02-09-2017)
My wife and I visited Old Mexico while in town due to the reviews. It was 5pm, and there was about 4-5 tables in the restaurant including us. About 5 minutes after being immediately seated, we got chip and salsa basically slammed down on our table by our waitress, and then she walked away. That alone nearly made us walk out, but we decided to be patient. We finally got the drinks we ordered over 10 minutes later. The waitress seemed to be in a terrible mood. After we got our food, she didn't bother to check on us until we were almost done eating. Her attitude basically ruined the meal. The food was just so-so. Not as good as we expected considering the reviews. Taco Bell would have been just as satisfying, and the service much much better. We won't be returning.
7 years ago (23-09-2017)
Really really really excellent... We're big on Mexican cuisine. I can tell you with 100% certainty - this place is the real deal. Nice atmosphere, friendly staff, and tremendous food. 5 stars!
8 years ago (09-07-2017)
Update: They've updated their menu to add specific vegetarian *and* vegan recommendations. But, if you're a meat eater, the carnitas are *amazing* (delicious bits of slow-cooked pork, crispy on the outside and soft and fall-apart flaky on the inside). We've eaten here three times so far. The carnitas were amazing! Reasonable prices. Easy-going but nice atmosphere. Service was great. And, although there aren't many vegetarian dishes on the menu, they can happily make many great vegetarian dishes, just ask. Many menu items have tasty substitutions. I was sad when Garcia's closed, but now that Old Mexico has opened, this is way better!
7 years ago (13-08-2017)
Comment on this business

to add Old Mexico Restaurant & Cantina map to your website;