Pegasus Coffee House

This is the perfect spot to get started on the Bainbridge Island trip. We arrived on a gloomy cold morning, and immediately fell in love with the cozy atmosphere. It was a little crowded on Sunday morning, but there's a heated patio available if you can't find seats inside. Parking is available for free in the adjacent parking lot or across the street. I ordered an Eggnog Latte and the Signature Avocado Toast on croissant. It was delicious, although I wished the croissant could be toasted. After breakfast, we took a walk on the waterfront trail in the back and there were some nice views.

Extremely cute coffee shop right on the water in Bainbridge. The coffee was delicious and I purchased a few bags to take home as gifts. The food was tasty as well. Staff members were nice and they are well organized when it comes to getting orders out quickly. Honestly, it's worth a trip even if you just take a picture in front of the building! Do yourself a favor and go inside!

We’ve been to Bainbridge many times but never visited Pegasus until our most recent visit. Our failure! It’s the best coffee spot in Winslow and the food is good too. We especially appreciated the story behind the founding of Pegasus coffee. Make sure to check it out on the far wall past the counter. It’s also in an historic building that was used as an assembly point when Japanese residents were rounded up and shipped to incarceration centers. Important part of Bainbridge Island’s history.

The place is pretty neat the location is right on the marina, building looks cool minus the old torn up patio roof ha coffee is high quality you can taste, tea was decent enough which was high quality but London fog was slightly off. Indoor is a little cramped but the patio is neat, there’s heaters but they weren’t on during this cold day.

I'd heard and read a lot about the place. The very first sight of the coffee shop from outside is really captivating. It has a nostalgic and welcoming vibe around it that is instantly inviting. Inside, me and two of my friends got a table to sit. We ordered a buttered croissant, a fruit muffin and Lattes. The croissant was good, the muffin was okay and the coffees were all good too. All in all a very pleasant experience.

Very atheistically pleasing cafe. The location is wonderful because you can grab a cup of coffee and walk the water front. They have indoor seating and outdoor seating as well. I tried the pumpkin pie latte and I liked it! I love how the latte wasn’t overly sweet like most places. You get that smooth light taste of pumpkin and just a hint of spice.

The perfect start to the morning. We stayed at the Eagle Harbor Inn for a romantic weekend getaway, and it was fantastic to be able to cross the car park and grab coffee and pastries to start the morning. Staff were super helpful, and the biggest challenge was choosing between all the pastries on display. The onion gruyere savory was superb; we could have eaten three of the apple tearaway; the blueberry scone was a fraction... a _fraction_ overbaked, but I'm now giving Great British Baking Show vibes. Highly recommended!

Casual coffee shop also offering a small menu. Had the breakfast sandwich, made fresh, quite tasty. Nephew had the waffles, also fresh & good. Very friendly staff.

Pegasus Coffee on Bainbridge Island is in an ivy-covered building, leaves turning yellow and brown when I visited. It looks like a house from a movie set! I grabbed a latte and sat by the street window for a while, then moved to the side patio to enjoy the rare sunny wintwer day. It is a lovely place, the atmosphere was convivial, the building is historic, the patio is cute and chic. So much so that I don't really mind the average coffee and the Macrina pastries I don't like.

Great ambience, staff and coffee. They have reserved parking area and serve vegan donuts. Inside and outside seating as well.