Hickory Pit

Coming from Texas, it is hard to find a good BBQ place around here to compare. Hickory Pit was really good- I had the pick two meat (pulled pork and sliced brisket). Meat had a good smoky flavor and they had a wide variety of sauce choices. I think the prices are a little high, but I would definitely come back here again!
8 years ago (27-02-2018)

This place is good. A rack of ribs for just over twenty dollars might sound to good to be true. This place is for BBQ lovers. My rack of ribs had a great smoke ring but not over smoked. One more thing that I judge harshly, cleanliness. Wow super clean.
8 years ago (15-02-2018)

I absolutely love this place, I was so sad when dons dairy frost went away, but this place is so good that it makes up for it! The cow pig burger is absolutely amazing I crave it constantly 😂😂, and all of the sauces are so good too, the experience I have had with staff members have been positive, and the restaurant itself is nicely decorated.. look forward to going back!
9 years ago (31-01-2018)

Great bbq at reasonable prices. Not crowded inside and fast service. Our new go-to place for bbq in McHenry.
8 years ago (24-03-2018)

Prices were a little on the higher side, so we were expecting great ribs & brisket (always happy to pay more for food that I'll want to add to my "must to again list". Food was mediocre, sides also, so we were disappointed.
9 years ago (04-02-2018)