Finelli's Authentic New York Pizzeria

Really enjoyed the two large new york style pizzas. We have had authentic NY pizza and this absolutely qualified. The crust was just crunchy enough and the texture and flavor was great. We ordered the sausage and cheese pizza and half hamburger half pepperoni/black olives. They had great prices and the food was ready on time and the place was clean. I would definitely go back when visiting bar harbor. Best pizza in town so far !

Veggie Delight Sandwich- beyond scrumptious and fresh. Bacon, mushroom onion pizza, yummy. We have been coming to the area for years, have never stopped. This will now be our go too place. Well done

Nice pizza place, tasted good. Wings were good too, I enjoyed the garlic parmesan sauce to dip them in.Food: 4/5

Delicious New York style pizza. they also sell it by the slice convenient for any quick lunch stop.Food: 5/5

I tried this cranberry walnut salad today for lunch..Everthing was fresh and delicious ..

It's okay. Edible. But definitely not great. The pizza crust was pretty good, sauce was lacking many aspects, toppings were cut too thick and the pizza was watery on top. The interior could use a lot of work. Stick to Dragonfire or Zeppas for Ellsworth pizza.Food: 3/5

Excellent New York style pizza. Had pepperoni 14"pie and white 12"pizza. The beer I had while waiting my order was delicious. The wait staff was conversational and engaged. Enjoyable experience.Food: 5/5

It used to be very nice, but it's been neglected over the years and is now a pretty dirty place to the point that it reminds me of the old Epi's in Bar Harbor where the premade food would sit out in the open collecting flies. The staff was not very friendly or accommodating on my last visit. I also found that the quality of the food seems to have gone down a lot over the past year or two. It's a shame, because this place used to be my favorite in the area. I really can't recommend it anymore, though. Sorry.

Some of the best pizza I've ever had the pleasure to eat. Excellent signature pizzas and great selections of craft beer. Quality ingredients and super friendly staff. Do not miss out on this gem.

Staff was very helpful and friendly. My pizza was amazing.Food: 5/5