Caterina's

Wow…Wow…Wow…how can something be SOoooo good be so depressing at the same time?! Well, on NYE…don’t remember how it came to me, but an idea popped into my head to go here. The draw back, it’s a two hour drive each way; the good, I actually like to drive. The last time we were here was almost 20 years ago!!! I actually remember the experience like it was yesterday! The wife and I was dating at the time and what a wonderful experience it was! The waitress was a much older lady and boy did she treat us perfectly! I remember cracking up, because she treated us like her children! We loved the experience! It made such a great impression that we always wanted to go back! Sad part is…life stepped in and 20 years later we finally went back to where it all started! Tonight was a special night…actually special day. The stars lined up and we get to have a reservation knowing it was busy and once again had a great time! This time we had a young punk serving us…she was GREAT! Thank gawd she didn’t treat us like the first waitress! Ha! Perfect timing with service and even the bus boys was good. Water filling was well timed. Drinks offer was perfect time when low. And the food…what can U say about the food…WOW!!! Very tasty and well seasoned! Both of our dishes were delicious and can’t wait for the next time. That’s the sad part of our story…can’t believe it took us 20yrs but hey, WE R BACK! We will make all attempts to go back more frequently, if they promise to keep this up! thank you for a fantastic experience!

A perfect place to enjoy an Italian dinner. Great staff, extensive menu of well prepared Italian food. I enjoyed every last slurp of linguini with clams. The salad, bread, and appetizer platter are also very satisfying before the meal arrives.

Ended up here randomly today after looking on Google maps for restaurants while I was in the area. Caterina's was the first one that popped up, and it was rated high so I headed over and was pleasantly surprised. I’m very picky when it comes to Italian food and everything was so fresh, all of the staff & patrons were in such good moods it was a great atmosphere. It was SO much food for the price. The tiramisu was very fresh and the perfect way to end The Weekend. Sadly I didn’t get a photo of my pasta, I was too busy eating it. Thank you!

Nice, friendly place. You can dress up or down but either way it's classy and you are welcomed. We had a reservation so experienced zero wait time. It's small but set up well. The food is great. There's an appropriate amount of wait time between arriving and ordering and eating. Our group of four adults ordered: Four appetizers: bruschetta, breaded conch, mozzarella marinara, and escargot. Two sodas, a glass of wine, and a whiskey drink. Three salads and a soup. Cod Vesuvio, Porterhouse, Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo, and Sea Scallops and Scampi. There was some kind of antipasto platter with a fresh garlic oil, and the fresh bread was to die for, both complimentary. Our bill was about $266. There was so much food that we didn't order dessert and had leftovers. Highly recommend.

I had the opportunity to eat dinner here last night. Everything was flawless! The friendly hostess showed us to our table quickly. The atmosphere was warm and friendly. Bread and antipasto arrived quickly, too. Our waitress was very friendly. She described all of the specials to a T. I ordered the pork chops Calabrese; my guest ordered lasagna. Both dishes were fantastic! Generous portions cooked very well. The service was absolutely perfect. Our glasses were never more than half empty, yet we didn't feel like the staff was hovering. A perfect dinner!

Wow ! Family owned ! Wonderful menu ! Great drinks. The Italian dishes are delicious. Veal Marsala is the best in town. You won't leave Hungry! Outstanding service! Never disappointed ! Owners are hands on and friendly!

Its so beautiful inside. Tje lighting is warm and cozy. The bread tasted awesome. The lasagna was the best i had from a restaurant. It was cooked. You can taste it wasnt frozen. The salad was amazing too. They brought out a dessert for my bachelors graduation! Thanks for the awesome experience. Id love to returnFood: 5/5

Atmosphere, drinks & service were great. Antipasto, bread with warm oil was very good. Dinners were flat, not seasoned at all. Butter & garlic we’re supposed to be on pasta had no taste at all. If we ever go back must be careful what we order.

Had clam and shrimp pasta. It lacked flavor. garlic butter over pasta and was minimal seafood for the price. Salad was over dressed and the charcuterie board was confusing. portions were large and to much overall. Service was awesome. Wished there was better lighting to see the menu not sure if i would returnFood: 2/5

Sad to find out that this Restaurant has to improve there services. We were treated unfairly first they said no seating then the waitress was rude, The manager making excuses for his employees, So sad that being a part of this community and living in Wisconsin for 33 years being business person so sad I did not enjoy my dinner had a bad experience. This is not going to be unknown, I was not asking for a discount or free dinner , I am a Latina business woman was trying to have a nice dinner. That place was referral to us, I would spend more money but felt uncomfortable. I could not even enjoy a drink, I will not recommend this place, they need to train there waiters and hostess, not to be so rude or Judgmental,