Cataro's Italian Villa

If you haven't had this pizza you are missing out. The thin crust special with pepperonis what my husband and I had. This is a well thought out made pizza. It's not just a bunch of cheese and toppings thrown on there it is a work of art. I can honestly say it's the best pizza I've had ever!!!Food: 5/5

Great food and amazing service! We had a big group of 13 people and they did a great job at serving us. The food is perfect portion sizes and the seasoning is perfect.

We had the pleasure of dining here tonight. It was our first time and we will be back we ordered the combo platter for appetizer it was abundant and very good, everything went there were five of us and we ordered three pizzas. First pizza was the large special, sausage mushroom and onion. Next pizza large sausage and pepperoni. Our last pizza that we ordered was a sausage and black olive medium. Excellent pizza we will be back whether it be dining in again or carrying out the wait staff was very friendly Pleasant and she accommodated all our needs. Excellent excellent excellent!

I loved it. I ordered the one with everything. They do not skimp on toppings and the crust is both flakey and crisp. I will order from them again!

Food was hot but bland. I ordered egg plant Parm. I got what they serve as appetizers with not much cheese and my red sauce on the noodles was tasteless. I hadn't been there in 2 years and I don't think I'll be back. My wife's food also was tasteless. Pass this up. I still tipped the waitress. It's not her fault when the kitchen puts out less than good food. This is a cash only establishment.

Superb thin crust pizza. Excellent flavor from perfect seasoning and toppings. So glad we tried it! Absolutely loved it and will certainly order again.Food: 5/5

Great place for Italian cuisine. The pizza is fantastic! The other guest had lasagna, which was also very good. The service is second to none very friendly and hospitable.

Nicest people in West Allis very clean dining area awesome customer service last but not least it's the best pizza around by far and the most reasonable price I love it I love the sauce it's amazing my fave definitely

Small family owned restaurant. Will definitely go back and order takeout pizza too.Food: 5/5

The pizza, cheese bread, breaded mushrooms and fries were fabulous!! Service was too!! Definitely returning soon!!Food: 5/5