Amicarelli Vineyard Italian Restaurant & Pizza

It has been nicely remodeled but the interior has lost much of its history and old world charm. The prices have increased as portions decreased. Less than a year ago it was the best Italian restaurant in southwest Mi now it's just another average restaurant in South Haven. Even the employees seem to have lost their work ethic that made it a top notch establishment. Although on our last visit we witnessed one server work her tail off for her section the rest of the employees didn't seem to care about the customers or the once great restaurant. The 4 rating was out of generosity and the past reputation. Otherwise it's really just a 3 . Hope this serves as a wake-up call for management before they run a once great restaurant into the ground.
8 years ago (31-08-2017)

The name and outside leads you to believe this is another upscale restaurant... the handwritten note on the door saying they were closed Mon-Tuesday should have given us a clue. Walking in and having Two people behind the counter not acknowledge us... the inside does not equal what you see outside. More of a drive-in type set up. I guess the glaring thing was looking at menus with many items scratched out in pen... Waitress nice.. food underwhelming.
8 years ago (16-09-2017)

Pizza was great. We arrived close to closing so menu was shortened to only order pizza That was fine and understandable. Services sucked. Server showed her dislike for us and I might add 3 other tables being there.
8 years ago (15-10-2017)

Worst Italian food I've ever had. We ordered chicken Alfredo, they gave us just Alfredo. I also ordered a pepperoni pizza which had only cheese, and a baked pasta with meat sauce. They gave me penne pasta with pasta sauce in the middle and no cheese. The food had no flavor. This was a carry out order so we were very disappointed when we got home. We will not be returning.
8 years ago (21-10-2017)

The last two times I have been here they didn't have the ingredients for the dish I originally chose. And the time before that they were only able to make pizza, due to staffing issues. Other than that the food is ok for the price.
8 years ago (04-01-2018)