Abigail's

Reasonable prices, and a decent atmosphere. My only complaint is an inconsistency with the food. For example, every time I have ordered the southwest chicken salad it has been different. One time it had tortilla strips, the next time it didn't. One time the chicken was cooked with a nice crispy exterior, the next time it was just bland, chopped chicken breast. I've experienced inconsistencies in everything I've ordered more than once. If they could maintain consistency with their dishes I'd give them a 5. While I know I won't like everything on a menu, I would hope if I liked it the first time, it would be prepared the same the second time. After all, even McDonald's can be consistent.
8 years ago (01-11-2017)

My mom and I went for her birthday lunch, the waitress was extremely rude and condescending. When we first got there we were waiting for quite a while to be acknowledged. A chef finally walked by and told us that we could sit wherever. We picked a seat and waited for quite a while before any waitress even acknowledged us. When we finally did get a waitress it was like we were inconveniencing her. She never even came back to offer drink refills, never notified us of any specials, and didn't come to check on us until after we were done with our meals. Food was decent, nothing too special. The poor service that we received is what ruined it for me. For that reason we won't be returning. There's plenty of other places to go in the Finger lakes that have much better service.
8 years ago (27-07-2017)

I love Abigails. When I was a kid my family went here a lot and I still enjoy it very much to this day! The food is very delicious and the wait staff is very pleasant. A couple nights ago I ordered for takeout and everything was fantastic. I wish I could give this review 10 stars, but 5 is the most Google will let me give. Keep up the great work :)
8 years ago (12-07-2017)

Despite the so-so reviews posted on yelp, we decided to try Abigail's. The restaurant was spacious & extremely busy due to opening day of the local three-day farm show in the area. Our waitress was awesome. She knew the local craft beer & made a good recommendation. The salad bar had good, fresh selections. My salmon was great, my fiancé enjoyed his broiled scallops & the kids' chicken parm were very good. Desserts were good too. We had a nice relaxing dinner due to crowd overflow from the farm show. If diners want fast service, then they need to seek fast food & not individually prepared meals.
8 years ago (09-08-2017)

Great service. Decent selection. Could use a better beer menu but all in all very nice.
8 years ago (16-10-2017)