Reviews, get directions and information for Which Wich Superior Sandwiches
Story
Grab a bag, our signature red Sharpie, and create your own masterpiece! Choose from more than 50 superior sandwiches, custom-crafted with the freshest meats, cheeses, and more than 60 toppings! It's your wich - any way you want it!
Address: 2177 Deming Way, Middleton, WI 53562, USA
related searches: Which Wich menu, Which Wich locations, Which Wich sandwich, Which Wich sandwich sizes, Which Wich near me, Which Wich Hours, Which wich superior sandwiches club Wich, Which Wich prices
Similar places near
Taco Bell
5 miles
This is easily the slowest taco bell I have ever been to. It doesn't matter if there ...
Ruth's Chris Steak House
49 miles
Wow, what a very attentive staff!! Very nice ambiance and just the perfect place for...
Smoothie King
92 miles
I love all of the different smoothie options here, there's something for everyone. An...
P.F. Chang's
95 miles
Our service was a little slow, but we were there on Friday night. Food was tasty, as ...
Monk's Bar & Grill Middleton
106 miles
GREAT food! Service was outstanding, quickly seated*, instant service at our table, f...
Arby's
124 miles
The food was good, I had a Double Beef n Cheddar, Curly Fries and a Jamoca shake. The...
Quaker Steak & Lube
139 miles
The service was friendly and made sure we had everything we needed. The food was just...
Costco Food Court
150 miles
Other Costcos- New York Larchmont and Wisconsin, Graphton carry Blue Hill Bay white f...
Capital Brewery
327 miles
Attended a private event here tonight. Great space, great bartender, great times!
Just the way we like it! Lots of options. Helpful calorie guide.
8 years ago (02-12-2017)
Excellent BLT if you like your bacon a bit smoky and crispy but not overly so. Service is usually quick. Orders with special options, however, are occasionally delivered
8 years ago (27-09-2017)
So many options you'll freak
If you grapple with decision-making, designing your own sandwich at Which Wich will freak you the hell out. Here's the daunting list of ingredient options that will need to mull over:
* 13 meats
* 2 breads and a lettuce wrap option
* Hot or cold
* 10 cheeses
* 4 mustards
* 4 mayo options
* 9 spreads & sauces
* 5 dressings
* 19 vegetable / miscellaneous (candied walnuts, perchance?)
* 7 oils & spices
Applying my admittedly feeble mathematical skills, if you wanted to make a cold sub on white with five ingredients, there are over 1.3 BILLION possible combinations. Granted, some options make little sense, the five dressing sub for instance, but still, you catch my drift on the issue of option overload.
Not wanting to deal with the plethora of permutations, I elected to order the prefabricated Philly Cheesesteak sandwich. While not as good as my go-to Philly at the Parkway Family restaurant, the Which Wich version was significantly better than your typical Subway offering (sorry, Jared). The toasted hoagie roll added some appreciated crunch and the sandwich brimmed over with well-trimmed, albeit slightly dry, beefsteak. The onions were more sautéed than caramelized, but hey, caramelized onions at a fast food restaurant, sign me up. At $7.50, I'd prefer a larger sandwich, but it was not a terrible value given the quantity and quality of the ingredients.
Like the quality of the food, the service at this location exceeded expectations. When the woman at the counter saw my confused expression when entered the store, she immediately explained the ordering process for me. She also asked what I thought of my sandwich and when I indicated it was slightly dry, she offered some suggestions on how to remedy the problem during my next visit. The restaurant appeared clean and well maintained, thought a little sterile. The prep time for my sandwich was over 10 minutes on a snowy night with a handful of customers, so I expect there may be a wait during the lunchtime crush.
While I don't see making Which Wich a frequent stop, I'll likely stop by again when I have time to ponder my several billion options.
8 years ago (01-12-2017)
Love this place. Tasty buffalo chicken sandwich and an Oreo shake, yum.
8 years ago (04-12-2017)
I have been to this Which Wich a few times and they have yet to disappoint me. Very good sub shop.