Tony's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

While the staff were great, the food just misses the mark. I decided to go with a ‘safe’ dish as I’ve never had any Italian food from this restaurant before. The sauce was over cooked, meatballs were burnt and the flavor was bland at most. It would take a lot for me to come back to this restaurant. On top of the poor food, the pricing is just not appropriate for what you’re getting. Highly recommend going somewhere else if you can.
7 years ago (23-02-2018)

One of my husband and I’s favorite Italian restaurants around! I’m from CT so I’m used to having tons of great options to chose from, so it is nice being so close to Tony’s! The food is always so delicious! My go to is the Eggplant Parmesan. The sauce has good flavor and it is covered in gooey cheese! Their salads are always very fresh, which is great too! The restaurant has a great view of the Puget Sound too, so that’s another plus. They also offer frozen pizzas and dishes up front in a freezer, which I cannot wait to take advantage of! The prices here are also quite reasonable, even for their wine, so a night out at Tony’s always leaves everyone happy!
8 years ago (17-12-2017)

Quaint Italian place that has been open for years. Rustic and charming with a nice view. Tony is long gone but the wait staff have been there forever. I would put them up against any restaurant staff. Great pizza.
8 years ago (27-12-2017)

This is definitely the best pizza in town. There's a reason why they been open for over 30 years! I love this place.
7 years ago (09-03-2018)

One star only because the manager didn't make me pay. Service is slow portions are small and price high. Pasta was of the frozen bagged varietie that you could buy at winco and reheat. And the marinara had no flaver and the whole dish was like warm. My family's food was good. But never going back. Bad birthday dinner. And in top off that I'm pretty sure they have not updated the decor since it opened in 1966. Tacky as can be and dingy.
7 years ago (23-03-2018)