New York Bagel Cafe

This place is a must try! Small and expensive but worth your trip. Lots of different eggs Benedict and you pick the type of bagel. Vegetarian also menu available. I tried the smoked duck eggs Benny with pumpernickel bread and it was delicious! I tried their moca. Options are available for any milk. Another must try is the homemade tiramisu cake. Absolutely one of the best I have had. I never would have walked in until I saw the menu. The place looks run down. But it looks like it would be crazy busy on the weekends. There is a patio, but good for the summer. I would go back again.
9 years ago (29-11-2017)

Slowest food service ever. However food was delicious and atmosphere was cozy. Only come here if you have a good amount of time to hang out here!
9 years ago (11-11-2017)

Poor service. Prepare to wait ten minutes before being greeted at the door. Two other tables walked out while we were waiting to be seated which should have been a warning. While I can acknowledge it was peak hours, the dining room indoors had only two tables seated while the patio was full - when we left after not being greeted at the table for ten minutes, two waitresses were chatting at the bar. Hot water and lemon runs you 3.50$ and a bagel platter is 18.00$. You're better served walking to the farmers market and picking up a half dozen bagels and some homemade cream cheese and eating at home. Can't comment on the quality of food.
9 years ago (15-07-2017)

Ordered the salmon lox bagel, indicated I just wanted the sandwich, not the meal because I don't care for potato salad. I received a cold bagel, cream cheese and salmon lox with no onion, no capers. I asked for this and she came out with a few capers and two slices of red onion, which I was charged six bucks for making the sandwich 19 dollars! No presentation, no love, no desire to please, we felt almost resented. I don't get what their problem is, I used to like this place. Never will return. Sad.
9 years ago (02-10-2017)

I like this place, but their costs do not justify the quality of food provided in my opinion. Its still great, just $$$$.
9 years ago (22-11-2017)