The Pies Guys Pizzeria & Fish Fry

Probably the best pizza in town. I've tried a few slices and they all have been great. They usually have lots of cheese, the tomato sauce is not too sweet or salty. We tried this place, GJP, and Cam's side-by-side and we liked this place the best. I've also tried the fish dinner. The batter was well seasoned and the fries were nice and crispy. I'll definitely be coming back and tried some of the other non-pizza options too

I stopped in on a quiet Sunday for lunch, the service was polite and quick, and the slices were the best pizza I have had in my 14 years of living in Upstate New York.

Ordered a simple ham and cheese sub. There was literally one, maybe two...slices of ham chopped up and spread out on a whole sub. Totally ridiculous. Won't order from here again.

Ordered chicken wings and haddock the other night and it was excellent haddock was perfect. The chicken wings were juicy and crispy on the outside., and absolutely perfect asked for the fry cooks name. His name is evan. Guy definitely knows how to whip up some good food. Will definitely will be seeing my business again!

The pie guys have a great business and they are friendly. I haven't tried all of their menu except for pizza and meatball subs bought many but it's goodFood: 5/5

Haven’t even eaten yet. The costumer service is amazing. My food was a little cold so they made me a whole new order at no cost.

Great pizza and wings! Tried for the first time when in town for a basketball tournament. Like the way the pizza was cut rectangular so that there was crust on every piece but still smaller slices than being divided triangular. Cooked perfectly. Nice crust. Cheese and pepperoni just right. Regular not sweet sauce. Really just a good piece of pie. Wings were extra crispy as requested but not overly done and the sauce…. Hot and absolutely delicious!!! The food was great, but I should also note that the employees were very friendly and you could tell they valued you as a customer. Something that you don’t see as often as you should! Thank you for a great meal after a long day of hoops!

We have gone often; and have never had a bad meal. The bread bowl salads are incredible! Pizza is pretty great too it’s like true NY’er style.

Ordered wings from this place late at night almost 9 pm on a Saturday for my family. Wings here aren't cheap either and I basically wasted that money. Order arrived at my door a little before the place closes, my family sits down to eat and these wings are rock hard, hurts to try biting through them. By this point it's too late to call and ask for the problem to be corrected cause they're closed. Call the next day and customer service is TERRIBLE. All I'm met with is resistance and no one wants to admit they made a mistake. Tells me they'll have to talk to the owner about it in order to do anything about it. Heard back from the owner and "Oh his wife was the one who sent the wings out last night and she said they were fine. We always crisp up our wings to make sure they don't go out raw." First of, how can your wife say they were fine by just looking at wings? Or did she try the order, I'm genuinely confused. Second off there's a difference between crisp and so overcooked you can't bite into them. I even offered to hand back over the burned wings as proof in exchange for my order being corrected. My advice is be careful ordering from this place, you've got staff and owners who are either to prideful to admit they made a mistake. Or they simply don't care. Don't waste money in burned food

Pizza was amazing! The taste was perfect! Hands down one of the best pizza places I've had I'll definitely order from you guys again! The staff was super friendly and helpful with the ordering process. I definitely suggest Pies Guys to anyone coming to the Oswego Area!