facebooktwitterpinterest
mobil menu

The Maids' Cottage

  1. Newmarket
  2. Newmarket Gluten-Free
  3. Newmarket Breakfast & Brunch
  4. Newmarket Sandwiches

Reviews, get directions and information for The Maids' Cottage

The Maids' Cottage
"We are open for take out only. We have retired our dine in services. We have a wide selection of frozen meals to take home and of course our famous buttertarts to enjoy! Delicious homemade dishes such as Mac&Cheese, Shepherds Pie, Meat Lasagna, Cabbage Rolls, and Meat pies."
Address: 223 Main Street S , Newmarket L3Y 3Y9, ON, CA
Phone: (905) 954-0202
State: ON
City: Newmarket
Zip Code: L3Y 3Y9


Opening Hours

Monday: 08:00-16:00
Tuesday: 08:00-16:00
Wednesday: 08:00-16:00
Thursday: 08:00-16:00
Friday: 08:00-16:00
Saturday: 08:00-17:00

Update Info

related searches: Maids Cottage menu, Maids Cottage take out menu, maids' cottage butter tart recipe, Bakery Newmarket, Best bakery Newmarket, Old Maids Cottage, Crow's Nest Newmarket, Pub Newmarket
Similar places near
Cafe Hesed Cafe Hesed 65 miles It a nice place and I believe the staff were doing their best. I had a carrot cake an...
Sun Star Bar & Grill Sun Star Bar & Grill 443 miles It is absolutely true that they have the best burgers in town. It is also true that t...
Wimpy's Diner Wimpy's Diner 456 miles It was good but could be better. I wasn't very happy with the hospitality of the serv...
Subway Subway 580 miles Writing this review as you today did not put cheese on or toast my wife's steak and c...
Big Bone BBQ & Wicked Wings Big Bone BBQ & Wicked Wings 1 km
The Wings Hut The Wings Hut 1 km So flavourful and the wings were great! Got the pound and a pitcher deal. Will defini...
Subway Subway 1 km Writing this review as you today did not put cheese on or toast my wife's steak and c...
Halibut House Fish and Chips Halibut House Fish and Chips 1 km Me and my husband visit here regularly the service we get is truly wonderful they rem...
Vince's Deli & Bakery Vince's Deli & Bakery 2 km There was a long line that usually means it's really really good. And all the reviews...
Chez Talal Chez Talal 2 km My friend took me here saying the Chez Talal has the most fresh and tastiest food. I ...
Haida Sandwich Haida Sandwich 2 km The worst expensive pizza I've ever eaten in my life. Old and dried French fries. A...
WingsUp WingsUp 2 km Great wings!! Crispy, meaty and delicious. We got 2lbs of the Hot BBQ and 1lb of the ...
Pita Pit Pita Pit 2 km
Daybreak Daybreak 2 km
The Buttery The Buttery 2 km We've decided to visit this restaurant as the reviews have been amazing, however we d...
Subway Subway 2 km Writing this review as you today did not put cheese on or toast my wife's steak and c...
Stacked Pancake & Breakfast House Stacked Pancake & Breakfast House 2 km
Daybreak Daybreak 2 km
Reviews
Finally, I had the chance to try the famous butter tarts from The Maid's Cottage. It is simply delicious. It is worth it to cross the city. The tarts are really special, taste so good, so fresh. Definitely, it is the best butter tart ever. All the different flavors make it even better. The lady who works there is such a nice person. The only problem is that the store is too busy, but I understand. Everyone wants the same nice things as me. Nice places usually are very busy.
A wonderful bakery centred on selling butter tarts in the heart of Main Street, Newmarket. The buttery smell of warm tarts hits you as soon as you open the door. The bakery is nicely laid out with a counter in the front displaying all of the goods. They don’t only sell tarts, they do also feature caramel apples, various squares and take-home goods. I got a half-dozen box of assorted tarts. They are a little pricy, however they are so worth it! One box of 6 tarts is $21 before tax. My personal favourites were the pecan and carrot cake tart. Highly recommend you stop on by and pick up some tarts from this lovely spot if you have the chance! pros: • Lovely interior and atmosphere • Great selection of tarts and other goods cons: • Pricey overall rating: 5/5
Best butter tarts I’ve ever had. Pecan has become my favourite flavour after having it here. No wonder it won the award for best butter tart. It is worth the drive!
The pecan butter tarts that we had for a breakfast with coffee was a amazing. These pecan tarts are so GOOD, a definite must try.
Best butter tarts ever!! Love that I can order online and pick up. Tons of homemade meals and delicious baked goods. Quick and friendly service! They rent out the dining space in the back for events too which is really nice.Food: 5/5
You know, I just can't seem to understand this place completely. They are open for limited times and not on any Sundays too I would guess they would make good money on Sundays right down on the main st? Then they still aren't allowing anyone to eat inside their place still? Only takeout and outside seem strange still. On a plus note, they do sell a great butter tart still.
Love Maids Cottage, this is a local go-to for butter tarts & pie shells. They have a lot of other delicious goodies. The staff are always friendly. I do miss the dinning room for breakfast but if it makes more sense to keep it as a take out/bakery only establishment I'm good with that.Food: 5/5
This Place has All the homemade comforts done with simplistic decadence. From their Famous Buttery tarts in flavor combinations you've never expected, to thier lovingly made take home premade meal options guaranteed to please everyone in the family, The Maid's Cottage is a Staple Gem to Newmarket's downtown district and a MUST visit for Any local or visitors who want to experience a Classic taste of Tradition at it's finest.
I respect this place has been around forever and is the jewel of Newmarket. Sausage rolls are fabulous. I used to stop by and order their brownies which I thought the best I ever had. After not being there for a few years, I've surprised recently to see they have changed them they now resemble cupcakes and they are now in a plastic clam shell packaging. Don't look homemade at all. The brownie still tastes the same although it's extremely thick and the icing is not what I remember falls off top of brownie, dry. They seem to be prepackaged in fours or twelve minis. I was so disappointed, they look mass produced and I don't understand why they changed them from the traditional squares with much less packaging. Unfortunately I will not be picking up brownies here again.
Honestly probably the best butter tarts that I have ever had. They get a perfect 5 for me!!! Great customer service and even better tarts. Delicious
Comment on this business

The Maids' Cottage map

to add The Maids' Cottage map to your website;



Copyright 2025 | All rights reserved.

You can use our top contact for adding and editing your business's information.
0.008 Loaded in seconds