Smalley's Inn

Went before Halloween. This place is not to be missed, the food is good and the staff is even better. They really go all out to make sure you have a good time, especially around the holidays. They do a lot of decorating for the Holidays. For Halloween, they really go all out...the have employees in costumes that scare the heck out of you. They walk around dressed as scary characters, hide in little nooks, and hide in plain sight. The guy hiding in plain sight is the one that made me yell "oh sh#@" He really made me jump. And one guy dressed as Jason gave me chills because he wouldn't speak, he just walked around with a fake knife in his hand and it was really creepy. Anyway, I didn't want to ruin anyone else's visit there so I didn't want to put this review up before Halloween was over. Definitely go next year, I know I will.
9 years ago (24-11-2017)

Being from Brooklyn I was actually pleasantly surprised by how good the food was. Tony is a treat - good time watching the Giants game there with him today. I had the gyro which was very good, my wife had the prime rib sandwich which was amazing! Contrary to one of the reviews the prices are too low; a cup of clam chowder is $2! And it was excellent!
9 years ago (24-09-2017)

Great place. Super friendly staff. Food is great! And it's really haunted, awesome!
9 years ago (27-11-2017)

You're Paying For The Halloween Decorations, Not The Quality Of Food. And You're Paying Fine Dining Prices For Pub Food. But The Halloween Decor Is Great.
9 years ago (28-10-2017)

The Halloween atmosphere is amazing. The food is a little lacking. :(
9 years ago (20-10-2017)