facebooktwitterpinterest
mobil menu

Sally's Sweet Shoppe

  1. Waukesha County
  2. Walworth County Bakery
  3. Waukesha County Bakery

Reviews, get directions and information for Sally's Sweet Shoppe

Sally's Sweet Shoppe

About

Bakery & Indulgent Treats *** A decadent, kitschy, small batch, from scratch bakery in the sweet, historic little town of Genesee Depot.

Story

All of the items we make here at Sally's are made from scratch using real recipes like yo' Momma did. We are an "open shop" bakery and you can see everything that goes on in our sassy little kitchen. We fill up our breakfast pastry counter every morning, bake at least three or four kinds of breads each day, work all day to fill up our two dessert cases, make decorated cakes & cookies and serve up our Hot Ham & Rolls (right outta the oven) on Sunday mornings. Getcher buns in here!

Life is sweeter when you indulge a little!

Products

Handmade bakery items and indulgent little treats.

Address: S42 W31370 WI-83, Genesee Depot, WI 53127, USA
Phone: (262) 968-1803
moc.oohay@eppohsteewssyllas
State: Wisconsin
County: Waukesha County
Zip Code: 53127


Update Info

related searches: Sally's sweet shoppe menu, Sally's sweet shoppe cakes, Sally's Sweet Shoppe photos, Sally's Sweet Shoppe Genesee Depot, WI, Sally's bake shop, Sally Sweets, Sweet Perfections, Sweet Confections Bakery
Similar places near
Mama D's Coffee Mama D's Coffee 4 km Cute kitschy coffee shop. Good drinks. Minus a star because there was definitely an a...
The Coffee Talk Bakery The Coffee Talk Bakery 5 km The bakery is incredible. And it is truly family run, when I found out the teenage s...
Walmart Bakery Walmart Bakery 9 km
Panera Bread Panera Bread 9 km Finished teaching at 8pm. Tired, hungry, and there's a real chill in the air. Wante...
Panera Bread Panera Bread 10 km Panera is dependable. The food offered is healthy. It is also offered in smaller size...
Great Harvest Bread Co. - Bakery & Cafe, Delafield Great Harvest Bread Co. - Bakery & Cafe, Del... 11 km Great tasting fresh food, a warm and welcoming atmosphere, friendly service, and an a...
Sally's Sweet Shoppe Too Sally's Sweet Shoppe Too 11 km Everything from cakes, cupcakes, to cookies that I have placed an order for has been ...
Walmart Bakery Walmart Bakery 11 km
Cafe De Arts Roasters Cafe De Arts Roasters 11 km Nice atmosphere. Lattes are yummy. Sandwiches are very tasty but a little pricey. The...
Blooms in Bloom Blooms in Bloom 12 km I am so glad we chose Blooms In Bloom for our wedding. The bouquets, corsages and cen...
Buttercream Bakery Buttercream Bakery 12 km This is such a cute little shop. They have a good variety of Mexican pastries, ice cr...
La Estrella Bakery La Estrella Bakery 12 km They have a little of everything For snacks and beverages for low prices for a small ...
Au Bon Pain Au Bon Pain 12 km Excellent service food and atmosphere
JusMemi Cake Design LLC JusMemi Cake Design LLC 12 km I went to JusMemi Cake Design yesterday to buy some bakery. My whole experience was ...
Cakes By Dakes Cakes By Dakes 12 km
Blooms In Bloom Blooms In Bloom 12 km I have been blessed to receive multiple bouquets from here. Absolutely fabulous and b...
Dunkin' Donuts Dunkin' Donuts 12 km Good service inside. A few of the donuts seemed a little old(started to dry out), but...
Bo's Bakery Bo's Bakery 12 km
Reviews
Have ordered many cakes for work and everyone has loved everything we have tried! They did our special school bus cookies for driver appreciation and they turned out fabulous!! It's terrific to have a local bakery to go to vs a grocery chain. If you get a chance the jumbo cinnamon rolls are to die for!!!
9 years ago (23-10-2017)
Wonderful selection, including gluten free, which are especially tasty. Been disappointed a couple of times when items didn't seem fresh. Hasn't stopped me from going back, though!
9 years ago (22-07-2017)
Would give a zero, but it's not an option. I went in to get information about cakes and cup cakes and Sally was there. I barely got a hello. When I started asking questions, she was very rude and kept telling me the info was on line. Horrible customer service! I don't care how good it could have been, you don't treat anyone like that.
9 years ago (29-06-2017)
It all started with ordering cupcakes for a gender reveal party I was having to announce the gender of my first baby! The cupcakes were TO. DIE. FOR! I can't express enough how awesome they turned out! With such a great outcome we ordered his first birthday cake from here and his smash cake, both of which turned out horrible! The cake was horribly dry and the smash cake had little to no flavor for a vanilla cake but it was cute and exactly what I wanted so at least our pictures turned out good! The day after the party I called and talked to sally and she was bummed to hear about the outcome and reassured me that she would make it up to us! So for his second birthday we tried ordering the cupcakes again which were free of charge! They ended up being horrible most were dry and had no flavor and the size wasn't what we were expecting. In addition my sons giant cupcake we got looked like a three year old made it and I'm honestly not exaggereating it was topped with a messy green, yellow, and purple frosting with sprinkles on it. To be honest I couldn't believe they let it leave their bakery. Luckily for them my husband picked them up the morning of the party because I was too busy getting things ready. This time I didn't bother calling and complaining and chalked it up as another party fail. This wasn't just any occasion we were giving these to our family and friends as a Thank You for coming to our sons birthday which for his first birthday it was embarrassing enough then a second year in a row no thanks. I am not sure what happened through the years here maybe the expanding, I don't know. But it is a shame. I have tried other treats from Sally's and they sure are good!! All in all I won't be making any personal orders from here anymore but we have found a new bakery were trying next year in Whitewater we tried their cake and cupcakes which were awesome all of which were very moist and perfect to the taste! Hope this helps anyone ordering personal orders! I would hate for anyone to be disappointed on a much more special occasion other than birthday parties!!
10 years ago (23-08-2016)
I enjoy my monthly runs to get my dogs food because I pass through Genesee Depot. I always get a sticky bun. Everything is great there, but if they are out of sticky buns I am devistated.
10 years ago (05-01-2017)
Comment on this business

Sally's Sweet Shoppe map

to add Sally's Sweet Shoppe map to your website;



Copyright 2025 | All rights reserved.

You can use our top contact for adding and editing your business's information.
0.0037 Loaded in seconds