S&P Oyster Co.

S&P is by far the best restaurant in Mystic. It is always clean and warm inside. The staff is always helpful and responsive. They have this incredible view of the drawbridge that is amazing during the warmer months. Their menu is perfect, but don't hesitate trying one of the chefs daily specials. I have never been disappointed with any of the specials. And save room for the bread pudding. I have gone there with my wife just for drinks and bread pudding.
7 years ago (24-02-2018)

Where do you take a distinguished visitor from the German Armed Forces?! We we're faced with having to choose a single restaurant that would best exemplify what Connecticut and Mystic has to offer. We called the staff at S&P, made reservations and asked for a table on the second floor overlooking the Mystic River. Our food was equally as impressive as the view. We started with native oysters, lobster bisque and the oyster stew. All were excellent! Our German had the Mahi Mahi special and raved about his first experience with the fish and loved the preparation. Our server was well prepared and offered several surf and turf combinations which my husband went with the N.Y. Strip and cod. Try any dish that offers the tamale with it - if that was an appetizer, I'd always get that!! Delicious!! Our guest will now be returning with his wife in July - the whole night was a home run and S&P has a new fan favorite from Germany 🇩🇪
7 years ago (22-04-2018)

It was no big deal. We wanted a lobster roll but they didn’t have any today. Nothing special. Should have checked out some other more interesting places.
7 years ago (05-04-2018)

We live in Mystic and this is our go to place for an excellent meal or a special occasion. Never disappointed. Servers very attentive and friendly, they take pride in their service and in the excellent food they are serving. The atmosphere is elegant and romantic with beautiful views day or night of the Mystic River and drawbridge. Anytime of year its a great choice but especially at Christmas time with the lights and decor. For the people with small kids who have written poor reviews, keep in mind that this is not a family style restaurant, it is fine dining. When I'm out having a dinner and paying for the atmosphere and quality of the food I'm getting I don't want to be distracted by screaming kids who don't know how to behave and who's parents can't control them! Think of other people not yourselves in this type of situation. You get what you pay for, and for Mystic this is a very well priced well portioned meal.
8 years ago (16-12-2017)

Great restaurant! Beautiful atmosphere, looking out on the Mystic River. Service was prompt and very friendly. Food was delicious. They have a great chef. Average prices for the area, but better food than most. Great selection too. There were a few good vegetarian options for me, and seafood options for my husband.
7 years ago (31-12-2017)