Pies & Pinups

What a gem! These pies were fantastic. Everything was freshly prepared and hot! Service was quick and friendly. Potato and cheddar was a favorite. I really enjoyed the blueberry pie as well. I will certainly be back! One of the best stops in Ithaca.

Great owners and amazing hand made pies. We ordered 2 sausage rolls and 2 irish mutton the night before to ensure they had them and collected just after noon today. They were freshly baked and oh so full of amazing flavors, awesome pastry and fillings. Please support this amazing little start up bakery.

WOW we heard this is a must and it is, we only got one but we will be going back for more and the salsa Verde is a must! So great!

Yummy, fresh, friendly. I’m not really a “hand pie” kind of person, but I saw this shop and decided to try it out. I’m a convert. The pies are filling and wonderful. The service is friendly. There’s a walk up window with covid. I recommend trying it out!

Some of the best food in Ithaca in my opinion, and that’s saying something! I cannot believe how crispy and flaky the crust is, and the savory fillings are AMAZING. They change up the flavors and always have something new to try, which is another reason I can’t stop going back. Good veg and vegan options.

AMAZING offerings, something to suit EVERY taste and dietary desire!! You've GOTTA try 'em!!

Low-key some of the best food downtown. Every single time I eat here to-go... the complexity of flavors, the consistent quality, and the range options... This is a one-of-a-kind place and they have honed their craft. Can't wait to see what's next in store for them.