Pastry Garden - Poughkeepsie Plaza

Horrible experience with this bakery!!! I called 2 months in advance about a custom graduation cake and was told to call back a week before. It is now 9 days before my sons party and I am told it is too late???? Will never go to this bakery again but will go out of my way to inform others of this inexcusable treatment.
9 years ago (01-06-2017)

Really nice service! Today I ordered my gender reveal cake and it was a great experience, they were the only bakery who knew what a gender reveal cake was and they could have it done right by the party date. Also picked up some cupcakes which were great, super excited for my cake!
9 years ago (07-04-2017)

What an incredible pastry shop. I LOVE their ice cream cake and moose covered brownies. The staff is very helpful. I have been there for 5 different occasions now in 2017 and every purchase has been a hit.
9 years ago (09-02-2017)

Would've been a lovely cake, but they covered the writing with one of the plastic decorations! "Happ- ---thday Emma" is definitely not what we were hoping for after paying almost $70. Very disappointed.
9 years ago (15-04-2017)

I had a baby shower cake made last year in April 2015, and it was beautiful! Tasted so great, everyone seemed to enjoy it. My son is turning one, and I figured since the last cake turned out so great I would order from pastry garden again. Well, I called two weeks ahead of the party, and described what I wanted for the cake. Called back a few days later to find out my plan could not be found so a nice young lady took my order again. She was very polite and patient with our order. Must have been the manager who called me back to confirm I wanted Elmo drawn on my sons cake rather than Elmo's face... I asked her politely what would work best on a cake that size, and she was just so rude for the rest of the conversation. Her attitude over the phone was nasty and I couldn't believe it. I was very disappointed to be treated like this after the fact the cakes cost came to $96.00. I wanted to make sure everything is right and hope that this cake comes out just as great as my first cake, because if not they have lost a customer.
10 years ago (26-05-2016)