facebooktwitterpinterest
mobil menu

Nico's Pizzeria

  1. Seward Place
  2. Schenectady County Restaurant

Reviews, get directions and information for Nico's Pizzeria

Nico's Pizzeria

About

Now introducing Nico's Rooftop Tavern!

Story

Nico's Pizzeria has been bring downtown Schenectady the best pizza and Italian cuisine for dine-in or delivery for over 15 years.

Now introducing Nico's Rooftop Tavern, our brand new pub-style restaurant upstairs, which offers a wider menu of fantastic dinners and drink specials. Follow us for our weekly specials and events!

Address: 441 State St, Schenectady, NY 12305, USA
Phone: (518) 372-6024
moc.liamg@airezzipsocin
State: New York
County: Schenectady County
City: Seward Place
Zip Code: 12305


Update Info

related searches: Nico's pizzeria seward place phone number, Nico's pizzeria seward place menu, Nico's pizzeria seward place delivery, Nico's pizzeria seward place reviews
Similar places near
Bombers Burrito Bar Bombers Burrito Bar 8 miles I got the ancho chicken chili burrito and was disappointed by how dry the chicken was...
Zen Asian Fusion Lounge Zen Asian Fusion Lounge 17 miles Everything was delicious here, from the mojito pitchers to the great deal on sushi ro...
Johnny's Johnny's 22 miles Nice place in Downtown Schenectady to get a drink at the bar or get a table for dinne...
Taj Mahal Restaurant Taj Mahal Restaurant 36 miles Not happy with my order. I was a repeat customer but lately the food is sugar and dif...
SUBWAY®Restaurants SUBWAY®Restaurants 40 miles These people ROCK! They were so helpful when we took a school trip to proctors. We le...
Ambition Coffee & Eatery, Inc Ambition Coffee & Eatery, Inc 47 miles Ambition is s quaint restaurant in downtown Schenectady, NY. It is decorated with al...
Aperitivo Bistro Aperitivo Bistro 59 miles Went for lunch. Ordered chicken caesar salad. It was okay, nothing amazing and turned...
Pizza King Schenectady Pizza King Schenectady 89 miles Best pizza in schenectady... It harkens to I Love.... in Troy. There is seating t...
Slidin' Dirty Slidin' Dirty 92 miles Delicious sliders perfectly cooked with many interesting options. Love the avocado fr...
Mexican Radio Schenectady Mexican Radio Schenectady 106 miles What other place do you know has 3 bars? Foods pricey and the portions are small but ...
Pho Queen Pho Queen 121 miles In the midst of average restaurants I found Pho Queen. It was wonderful. Quaint an...
Tara Kitchen Tara Kitchen 149 miles First visit to Tara kitchen. Sat at the bar, food was amazing. Fun to watch the food...
Katie O'Byrnes Restaurant Katie O'Byrnes Restaurant 173 miles I make a rule of not posting reviews, but I absolutely must. I stumbled upon this pub...
20 North Broadway Tavern 20 North Broadway Tavern 197 miles Kitchen staff does does amazing job. Food is excellent. Bartenders want to be more fr...
Burger King Burger King 218 miles This location has been remodeled in the last year so it is clean and new. Staff are ...
Mad Jack Brewing Co. at The Van Dyck Mad Jack Brewing Co. at The Van Dyck 281 miles I have seen some great Blues and Folk singers there. It's the best place for food ...
Slick's Restaurant Slick's Restaurant 312 miles QUIET,COZY PLACE WITH GREAT SANDWICHES LARGE ENOUGH TO FEED TWO PLUS TAKE HOME FOR MO...
Manhattan Exchange Manhattan Exchange 312 miles Great place. Excellent food at a great value. Every Wednesday is Burger Day! If you'r...
Reviews
I am extremely disappointed with this restaurant. This one has some history, so sit tight. A number of years ago, 8 to be exact, I began college in the area with some of my former classmates. While deciding on where to go for lunch, we discovered Nico’s Pizzeria. This is where my displeasure for this restaurant truly began. We had a simple order that afternoon; 1 order of garlic knots to share with a side of marinara. Although I am unable to recall the quality of service, I do remember receiving an aluminum pan full of half burned, half uncooked garlic knots. Needless to say I was disappointed. About a year later, I landed a full-time job in the area, and needed to find a decent place for lunch. I decided that Nico’s, being the nearest pizzeria, deserved at least another chance, especially since a year had passed. Their pizza was passable for a quick grab-and-go option when I didn’t have time for much else. Over the next few years, I became a semi-frequent customer going at least every other week. At one point I had been introduced to the manager/owner by a mutual friend and we became close acquaintances. We eventually reached a point where we would greet each other on a first name basis, and without needing to ask, I was brought a drink (Dr. Pepper, which was unavailable on the second floor due to not being included on tap) and asked if I’d be having my usual, off-menu selection. I was a happy regular, visiting every now and again for my off menu lunch and being treated with kindness, respect, and always a friendly chat with the owner. That being said, I was never very impressed by the quality of food here. I still never increased the frequency of my visits and avoided their menu almost religiously. I have never had a piece of pizza that didn’t have undercooked crust, and when ordering slices from the counter downstairs I rarely received a piece that was above tepid at best, even upon specifically asking for them to be “extra hot”. My recent encounter at this establishment will be my very last. After a long day at work and in preparation for a birthday celebration for a friend, I found myself at another local restaurant. After ordering my food, the group had decided to meet at Nico’s rooftop for the festivities. I arrived first, and seated myself at a small table and continued eating my food, awaiting my party’s arrival. I found myself alone aside from two other guests and a very loud, opinionated waiter. I was never greeted. And the opinions that were being expressed by the staff to other customers were making me very uncomfortable. Upon my party’s arrival, I was finally greeted along with the rest of the group. The waiter took our order for drinks and was about to be off when she noticed my meal was from elsewhere. She made no hesitation in letting me know: “I’ll let it slide this time. But if the bar manager sees you, it will cause trouble.” I very politely apologized and mentioned that I knew the bar manager personally and didn’t think it would be an issue since we had just ordered drinks and were planning on spending the rest of the evening as happy patrons. I was told not that it would “probably be fine” and the waiter hurried off, I assumed to retrieve our drinks. Not 5 minutes had passed before we were approached by the bar manager, whom I greeted by name assuming we were still cordial. It started innocently enough with small-talk, however quickly became extremely uncomfortable. I was again accosted about having outside food. I attempted to let the my acquaintance know about the drinks we had JUST ordered and our plans to stay for the evening, to no avail. I was again told: “I’ll let it slide this time, just don’t let it happen again.” I was very upset. I packed my belongings and left. On my way down the stairs to leave, I noticed our waiter headed back upstairs empty handed, clearly expecting us to have been asked to leave. I was so upset, I forgot to grab my food as I left with my head hung in shame. Miss Janet, if you ever read this, please know that I am very deeply hurt. I wish you well.
9 years ago (22-08-2017)
Good pizza place... New York City Style Pizza.... I prefer Pizza King right around the corner on J Street... But this pizza is a close second.
9 years ago (06-11-2017)
Good food. Good service. My godson loves the PB&J wings. My server, Cassie, was awesome! She even posed for a pic with my godson.
9 years ago (09-10-2017)
Went there with my son. Good food and large portions. Would be nice if they had child size portions on the menu but otherwise a great experience.
9 years ago (22-09-2017)
Nico's is awesome! Be sure to go up stairs to the best bar in downtown Schenectady. I haven't had one meal i didnt like. Try the grilled chicken sandwich!
9 years ago (02-09-2017)
Comment on this business

Nico's Pizzeria map

to add Nico's Pizzeria map to your website;



Copyright 2025 | All rights reserved.

You can use our top contact for adding and editing your business's information.
0.0042 Loaded in seconds