New York Pizzeria is your premier, authentic New York style pizzeria! For low prices and high quality, come grab a slice at New York Pizzeria!
New York Pizzeria in both Cooperstown and Richfield Springs, NY is your leading local pizzeria!
Bite into the cheesy goodness of some of New York’s most delicious, traditional pizza around! Specializing in both classic pizzas and our own gourmet pizzas, come in and make your own pizza or try one of ours! Using only the freshest ingredients available, each slice is even better than the last! Our famous Buffalo Chicken Wing Pizza combines the best of two classic worlds, while our Stuffed Pizza is a New York Pizzeria original! Whatever your taste buds like, come in and we’ll make it for you.
Aside from pizza, New York Pizzeria offers a wide menu of other favorites such as calzones, chicken wings, subs, hot subs, and grilled sandwiches, wraps, salads, pastas and Italian classics such as Veal Parmigiana! With so much to choose from, bring in the whole family and we’ll have you covered.
Open 7 days a week, make any day a special occasion with New York Pizzeria! Available for dine-in, take-out, or delivery we make it easy and convenient for you. Next time you’re in search of a delicious, authentic New York Pizza- come on in for a slice!
Mel's at 22
289 miles
First time during busy Saturday afternoon. Staff handled being "in the weeds" very p...
Alex's Bistro
301 miles
Food is eclectic and interesting. Lamb lollypops were very good. Scallops and pork be...
Cooperstown Diner
339 miles
I'm always on the lookout for a great diner, and this place was no exception. We mus...
Sal's Pizzeria
354 miles
The pizza was good but the service was NOT!! First and last time there, we walked in...
Nicoletta's Italian Cafe
364 miles
My husband, dad and son had an amazing meal and amazing service! When they left, they...
Tunnicliff Inn
391 miles
What a lovely place!!! Everything needed was provided and the people were very hospit...
Bocca Osteria
481 miles
Food was excellent, try any of the specialty pizza's. Try the oil and vinegar with b...
Lake Front
516 miles
First of all, this isn't a hotel; it's a motel. Second and worst, the picture showing...
Hawkeye Bar & Grill
522 miles
Fantastic restaurant, very cozy dining area. The food was excellent and the wait staf...
Dining Room at The Otesaga Hotel
525 miles
Attended a wedding everything was excellamt, food unbelievable, service first rate
Upstate Bar and Grill
561 miles
Went here before their official grand opening so things are still changing but overal...
Blue Mingo Grill
4 km
Don't bother going, we made a reservation for 7:30 did not get seated until 7:50 afte...
The Shack
5 km
Perfect for small parties looking to avoid the baseball crowd. Small menu became even...
Council Rock Brewery
5 km
This quaint spot was a surprise, but a welcome one. The layout is a little weird, wit...
Fly Creek Cider Mill & Orchard
5 km
Stopped here on a Cooperstown trip and it was worth the stop. Didn't know what to exp...
McDonald's
6 km
This location does great with accurate custom orders but takes forever for any order ...
SUBWAY®Restaurants
6 km
Worst subway experience I've ever had. One of the two employees was very rude to me a...to add New York Pizzeria map to your website;
