Lake Geneva Pie Co

You can never get a slice of pie, they're always too warm to cut according to the employees. How can you be called a pie co if you won't serve said pie? No idea. Been out here several times same result. Won't bother next time.
8 years ago (27-09-2017)

I haven't tried everything they offer, but what I have tried is wonderful. The breads and muffins are moist and full of chocolate chips or fruit. The pies are fantastic!
8 years ago (12-10-2017)

Love this place. Started the weekend there with a little quiche for breakfast. It is the best. So good, we decided to order a gourmet sandwich to go for later. It is a stop when ever in town.
8 years ago (11-09-2017)

You have got to be joking...a pie for twenty bucks?!?? They are advertising their 15 year anniversary, and I can only wonder who continues to buy $18 pies regularly, in order to to support the company. Seems like a nice place, but the prices dictate a customer base that must really have a pie fetish, or are independently wealthy. God bless them though, that they seem to be successful. I bought one anyhow, for a gift, then went next door and bought a $4 pie for my family at Piggly Wiggly...no worries.
8 years ago (29-05-2017)

Had the strawberry rhubarb pie. Was delicious, you could tell the crust was homemade & fresh. Their sandwiches are very good & made to order.
8 years ago (14-09-2017)