Itty Bitty Pie Company

I prefer Pie over Cake for my birthday. So this year my husband looked online for Pies to surprise me with and found Itty Bitty Pie Company. He had me meet him there, the owner was welcoming, knowledgeable, accommodating, and super nice. She understands us "Pie People" and our love of all things Pie! We bought a Buffalo Chicken mini pie and a Steak with Guinness mini pie for lunch. The crust was flaky and just enough to cover the filling, so perfect! Our mini pies were amazing, so full that we were both stuffed by the time of finishing our "pie." She had suggested putting blue cheese dressing with the Buffalo Chicken mini pie, which was perfect as it does have a bite to it. We ordered a Strawberry Cream Pie and a Coconut Cream Pie for tonight, which were delicious. My mother-in-law is very picky with her desert, and she loved the amount of whipped cream to custard in them. Everyone enjoyed them, saying they were the best ever! We will definitely be returning, can't wait to try more, and her vegan options are amazing!

The quality seems to have gone down over the years. When they first opened everything was outstanding and maybe it's because they've expanded to making other kinds of pies beyond the 'sweet' pies, that the mini pies aren't as good as they used to be sometimes overbaked, far too much graham cracker crust - sometimes a bit burnt tasting - and little filling in the Strawberry Mississippi Mud pie, cream-to-filling ratio. Still very much worth a visit given how unique it is.

Haven’t tried any of the “sweet” pies but I do love the savoury pies! Jamaican pie taste just like a Jamaican patty!!! This place is way better than Hamilton meat pie co! I just grabbed a cabbage roll pie the other day and I can’t wait to try it!

We ordered the apple crumble, apple with pastry top and pecan pie for Christmas. They were all delicious. We will be ordering again very soon. Thank you!

My first Itty Bitty experience did not disappoint! While the store itself was just, a store that could use little cleaning the mini pies were mouthwatering! They were a bit pricey and you only save $1 buying four however, they were very delicious and the crust was scrumptious.

My daughter was suppose to get a pie on her birthday delivered, the customer service was disgusting to say the least. Upon first walking into this place as we had to pick up it looks dirty and unkept. The first view of the pie, which was left on the counter the crust is thick and dry. She wants to keep the delivery fee, which is 15.00 after cancelling the delivery on my daughters birthday, then rescheduling and cancelling again, now she’s arguing about keeping the delivery fee when we had to pick it up, I wouldn’t recommend this place to anyone. If I could give zero stars I would.

Amazing pies and very friendly staff! We used Itty Bitty Pies for our wedding in October 2019 and the pies on a stick as well as the mini take home pies were a huge success! We absolutely love how many vegan options they have. My favourites are the vegan Jamaican patty and the pesto veggie. It’s also great to know that all of their fruit pies are vegan as well! I would recommend them to anyone!

The caramel apple crumble made here is one of the Best pies I have ever tasted. They are made with love and worth every penny! My Dad used to buy pies for weekend guests at the cottage this one would be a hit!

We've only tried the sweet either fruit or cream based pies but have been incredibly happy with everything we've ordered. Our family's favourites in no particular order are the lemon meringue, apple cranberry, key lime, and the coconut cream. We've never been disappointed with picking up an assortment of the mini pies, and I highly recommend picking up a few next time you're in the area.

Amazing pies. We got and apple pie and a mixed berry crumble for Thanksgiving weekend. Both were some of the best pies I've ever had. The crust is so flaky and thick. I like buying them frozen and then cooking at home.