Italian Fisherman

The place is upscale and a great location. Their community involvement and contribution is unparalleled. The food is above average, but do not expect a real Italian style restaurant. It has rather limited choices of "Italian foods" and the pastas and sauces are average at best. You pay for the location, and that is expected in so short a season. No problem. Go here and enjoy.
8 years ago (18-08-2017)

Food was very good. Service was great as well. They gave the option of sitting outside with a casual menu or dining inside with a gourmet menu. Ended up eating inside. Food was nicely presented - cheapest entree was $25.00
8 years ago (04-07-2017)

Probably a little pricey for the quality but it is very good for a great location. Parking can be difficult sometimes. I've enjoyed every dish I've had. Place is clean although bathrooms are very small. Definitely worth the trip from Erie for a birthday dinner.
8 years ago (10-07-2017)

Kimberly was the best waitress I've ever had! She was super attentive and friendly! Kimberly offered great suggestions and gave us a great dining experience! The Italian Fisherman needs more servers like Kimberly because this girl is going far in life and won't be here forever. Get her as a waitress while you can!!!!!!
8 years ago (06-08-2017)

Incredibly overpriced establishment that takes advantage of a captive tourist audience in the summer. Server was not very forthcoming when asked about portion sizes. Had a very good beet and goat cheese salad but absurd as an appetizer at $13. Pasta dish was bland and unremarkable. Could have had a better meal at Olive Garden for a third of the price. Beamus can be a tourist trap in general.
8 years ago (21-08-2017)