Hoosier Mama Pie Company

Places like Hoosier Mama Pie Company are why I’m so jealous that I don’t live in Chicago. They offer several different pie slices, mini pies, and full size pies. Savory and sweet. They also do coffee and espresso drinks. It’s just so cool that there’s a little old school pie shop with seating options to relax and enjoy a gorgeous slice. I had the cardamom blueberry and it was one of the best pieces of pie I’ve ever had. So nice on a rainy day, or a sunny day, or for no reason at all. The woman helping me was incredibly kind too. Well worth a walk or going out of your way for.

There is one staff at the counter so the line can be really long if it's a busy day. The decor is very old fashioned. The menu is huge. There's a sanitizing scent when I'm in the store so I was concerned that the pie may not be fresh... I ordered chocolate cream slice and it's okay. It has good amount of cream and chocolate fillings but have to say that I've had better pie

A true blast from the past vibe! The interior feels like being transported into a diner from the 50s. The seating area and shop in general is not too big, and there are two big booths that have nice big windows to people watch! The booths do get a little hot and stuffy though when the sun is bright. I adore how you could get pies by the slice here, and they have so many flavors available! I got the espresso cream and lemon chess pies, and they were delicious. The lemon chess was a classic and the espresso cream had a great balance of flavor, depth, and texture! You could also see the pie making process in the back as well! The staff were helpful and welcoming as well. Cant wait to visit again! :

Hoosier Mama is such a great spot for coffee and pie. We went early on a Wednesday morning and sat outside! The iced coffee with the oat milk topper. I found easy parking outside. I will definitely be back soon for another piece of pie soon!

Omg. What can I say? I thought I was a fan of chocolate pie until I had their fruit. My husband and I got 3 slices of pie, a cookie, and a handpie lamb and apricot!. The handpie was so good, we waited in line and ordered 3 more right then and there. The girls behind the counter were working SO hard. The cashier was also making and filling the orders. Go with patience and a smile and you will be rewarded with fantastic food.

I really enjoyed the spinach pie, and then all of the other sweets!!! You really can't go wrong!! The Kikwetu Kenyan Coffee that they serve as a specialty coffee pairs well with their bakery!!!

Delicious savory items. We had the mushroom goat cheese hand pie, the spinach artichoke galette and the chicken pot pie. The dough is fabulous and the fillings incredible. The chocolate pie was great. The bottom crust so thin and flaky and the edge thicker and flaky. I thought the banana pie was too sweet for my taste. I can't wait to try some fruit pies! I will definitely go back for the savory items. The interior is cute but only 4 tables. There is a patio for warmer weather. Staff were friendly and patient.

Lovely pie shop. Feels very welcoming and cozy. The staff was quick and friendly. Ordered a slice of the fruity pebble and pecan pie. Very tasty, flakey/buttery curst. The fillings were pretty balanced didnt taste overly sweet. Also ordered a small banana cream pie, it was a hit at the party. Definitely would be back for some pie.

Stopped in today and picked up a slice of pie for dessert. Haven't been here for years. I chose the caramel apple custard pie slice. Pie crust was flaky and flavorful. Apple flavored custard was delicious, with just the right amount of caramel. Not overly sweet. Will soon be going back again.Thanks!

THE. BEST. PIE. I. HAVE. EVER. HAD. My favorites are buttermilk and banana cream. Cute little shop to hang out too. One of the few dessert places in Evanston! Be sure to order ahead if you want a pie for Thanksgiving, Christmas or Pi Day because they do sell out.