Historic Village Diner

Delicious and simple diner food done right. There aren't many restaurants in the area and when you find a restaurant you have to make sure you go in to grab seats fast. The historic village diner looks like your average diner on the outside but once you step inside and try the food, it puts other diners to shame. First of all the portion sizes are humongous, the way things should be. Second the food tastes great, we came in as a group of 13 and all of food was cooked perfectly. I ordered the Lock Horn special and it was delicious, the roast beef was piled so high I had to take 2 bites to get everything. Also I chose to pair it with sweet potato fries which came with the petal sauce, delicious stuff. This is a great place to eat after a day of kayaking/hiking/driving or just if you're passing by.
7 years ago (15-12-2017)

Went here based on all the reviews.... we had a terrible experience! We got there at 11:30am my husband, myself and 3 kids. You would think we walked in with a dozen people. We had to wait 20 minutes to be seated, it took another 10+ for the waitress to come over and take our drink order, another 10 to bring the drinks when she finally came to take our order she said they were no longer making pancakes or French toast, exactly what we were ordering! Apparently they stop at noon. Had they sat us in a timely manner or even took our order we would have had plenty of time! The worse part... the people that came in after but were seated first had pancakes! The food we ordered was nothing special, not even cooked well. They advertise bottomless coffee... my husband got one cup asked for a refill twice, never got one. The service was terrible, food mediocre at best. Oh and the highchair was disgusting! I was stuck holding my 9 month old the entire meal. I just don't know how they have such good reviews! Extremely disappointed, will not be going back!
8 years ago (01-08-2017)

Classic diner, great staff. Hometown pride! Consistent & delicious, Americana!
7 years ago (26-12-2017)

Amazing food and wonderful service! Had an omelet with has browns and toast. It was so good!!
8 years ago (18-11-2017)

If you get a speeding ticket on the Taconic & have to appear at Milan Town Court, soothe your soul afterwards at Historic Village Diner. Never have I thought the best part of my breakfast would be the toast. The main attraction was my omelette of course, but everything was cooked to perfection. The staff are super friendly & take time to make sure you're satisfied. If I lived in town, I'd be here all the time...it's the local greasy spoon with A+ presentation and service.
8 years ago (19-08-2017)