Goodys Pizzeria Bayside

Great place! The pizza is excellent and the service was great. I'll definitely go back.Food: 5/5

By far the best wings I've ever had! I'd never heard of this place before I met my wife, and she always ordered pizza from here when we were first dating and sent me to pick it up since delivery was out of the question. It's small enough that even to this day it's easy for me to pass it and have to turn around at the next intersection to get back to it, and there aren't many parking spaces. Now they serve wings which are gargantuan and they have the 40 Creek BBQ sauce which has to be my favourite flavour. I last went with my dad while my wife, mom and kids went to a park to wait for us. We got six servings 1 lb each of wings and a large serving of fries and it came to nearly $100, but everyone loved the food.

I heard all kinds of good reviews about Goody's, so I decided to check it out after finishing work early. Walked in and ordered, took 12 mins for a fresh pizza with 3 toppings. Very fast, and the ladies were very helpful and wonderful! No complaints, and will be returning again!

Was in Trenton for the weekend and decided to support a local family owed business instead of the regular chain pizza place. This place was somewhat more expensive than a chain restaurant, but that was to be expected. What also was expected was a higher quality due to the price. Food was just alright. The pizza was unexpectedly small for a large pie and the toppings just fell off. Meanwhile, the wings looked like the sauce was just squirted out of a bottle into the takeout container. For the price, I would have much rather gone to a chain place and spent probably 25% less for a more consistent quality.

Seriously best Greek salad I have had. Portions are huge and just delicious

Top notch pizza..has surpassed Jim's in Trenton as the benchmark in the area in my opinion...which was the best far and wide .

They make really good homestyle Pizza here and they were quick with delivery. I recommend.

Worst place the get pizza. The pizza did not taste right, the cheese smelled rotten. Worst customer service. The staff were gossiping about the customers and were very rude. My younger sister left her belongings on accident and the owner claimed it wasn’t there.

We were disappointed in our pizzas. We tried them a few years back and loved them. Last night the pizzas were very disappointing. The toppings were dry and fell off the pizza. The cheese was solid . It didn't have the melting quality that one thinks of with pizza. Nothing stretchy. One piece was enough for us and we won't be back.

Great service and prices! They make a wonderful chicken Caesar wrap that makes lunch seem homemade, lol! Thanks!!