facebooktwitterpinterest

Goodfellows Restaurant

  1. Mackinac Island
  2. M Kinac Food
  3. M Kinac Restaurant
  4. Mackinac County Food
  5. Mackinac County Restaurant

Reviews, get directions and information for Goodfellows Restaurant

Goodfellows Restaurant

About

The Wine Cellar offers a full service wine tasting bar, with wine flights, an extensive flatbread pizza menu for lunch, and an upscale dinner menu.

Story

An Intimate Dining experience on Mackinac Island, Down Town on main street with a view of everything. Come join us for a dining experience you won't soon forget.

Address: 1359 Hoban St, Mackinac Island, MI 49757, USA
Phone: (906) 847-0260
moc.tnaruatserswollefdoog@sirhc
State: Michigan
County: Mackinac County
City: Mackinac Island
Zip Code: 49757


Opening Hours

Monday: 8:00 AM – 10:00 PM
Tuesday: 8:00 AM – 10:00 PM
Wednesday: 8:00 AM – 10:00 PM
Thursday: 8:00 AM – 10:00 PM
Friday: 8:00 AM – 11:00 PM
Saturday: 8:00 AM – 11:00 PM
Sunday: 8:00 AM – 9:00 PM

Update Info

related searches: Mackinac Island restaurants
Similar places near
Cawthorne's Village Inn Cawthorne's Village Inn 20 miles Great food, great service, highly recommend. It. Located Off the main street on a sid...
Mary's Bistro Draught House Mary's Bistro Draught House 37 miles As a vegetarian, I found the choices lacking at this restaurant. The food tasted pre...
The Chuckwagon The Chuckwagon 52 miles Breakfast at the Chuckwagon was interesting and delicious. We sat at the counter-seat...
Carriage House Carriage House 78 miles Best on the Island. Great food and a fantastic view.
Seabiscuit Cafe Seabiscuit Cafe 96 miles Food was quite flavorful & delicious. The quantity was substantial. Our waitress & th...
Mustang Lounge Mustang Lounge 100 miles Just got a stake and was the worst stake I ever ordered the service was not very good...
Yankee Rebel Tavern Yankee Rebel Tavern 108 miles Man the food is good here! We decided to have lunch here on two different days (3 day...
Mighty Mac Hamburgers Mighty Mac Hamburgers 113 miles Great place on the island for a burger and fries. Great hot dogs too! Beautiful view ...
Horn's Gaslight Bar & Restaurant Horn's Gaslight Bar & Restaurant 129 miles In October, I visited Mackinac with a friend and some of her family. We Stopped at t...
Millie's on Main Millie's on Main 136 miles Chose to go here last minute when I was visiting Mackinac last week and it far surpas...
Pancake House Pancake House 160 miles The name says it all. Great breakfast with a fast and friendly staff. I recommend the...
Mama La Rosa's Pizza Buffet at the Murray Hotel Mama La Rosa's Pizza Buffet at the Murray Ho... 160 miles It's a good place to eat quickly wen you are hungry.
Sushi Grand Sushi Grand 161 miles If I could give it more stars I would. I haven’t been able to find a sushi restaurant...
The Gate House The Gate House 161 miles Incredible food, very friendly staff. Music selection was on point, we were going to ...
Island Slice Pizzeria Island Slice Pizzeria 171 miles 🍕Best pizza on the island!!!! We went there three times while we were there. Pizza is...
Pink Pony Pink Pony 180 miles Pink Pony was a great place to grab lunch on the island. The famous rum runners were ...
Fort Mackinac Tea Room Restaurant Fort Mackinac Tea Room Restaurant 270 miles Food was okay but you really go for the view. We were lucky to have a nice clear day...
1852 Grill Room 1852 Grill Room 331 miles Good food and cocktails. Not a bad price all things considered. It is a bit silly t...
Reviews
Very good cocktails after the city tour. The food too was pretty decent. Though some disappointment with the jackfruit tacos which turned out to be sweet. But the staff took care if it and put it off our bills. The Mules are definitely a must try. Spacious enough for big groups too. Loved the vibe of the place. A nice bar setup with a catch Tag - wings and things!
My husband and I ordered the white fish and chips, because, you know, when you visit an Island you want to eat some seafood. It was definitely a good choice! Good food, affordable prices, good service and it was clean. The reason I gave 4 instead of 5 stars is because I would prefer it to be cleaner outside and as you can see on the photo there are two fish filets, so it would make sense to put two cream sauces or a bigger one. I was not the only one who asked an extra one. By the way, it was a lot of food!
As a guest at the adjoining Lakeside Hotel, we enjoyed most of our meals here during our 2-night stay. The food was very good but also very pricey. For example the crab cakes appetizer shown in my picture were $16! The service was excellent but the dining area was very basic and in need of an update. We mostly ate here because we had a $100 voucher from the hotel. There are probably more reasonably priced options on the Island to choose from than this place.
Best place on the island for food and drinks! Waitress was on it! Smart about the menu and very attentive to the needs of our party! Highly recommended!!! I'd give this place a 10 star rating. Was here 3 yrs ago and still the best ever!!! Huge salad and best perch!!!!!
There are so many other places to eat it's hard to say this place is any more than just Ok. There were 4 families here when we came, while we were there another couple came and was seated behind us. Their table wasn't clean. It was 5:30pm. Seems rather inexcusable considering how early it was and how empty this place was. The food we ordered, was adequate but sat heavily like a rock. We didn't order anything fancy and ate off the light menu. But I don't think we'll be returning. One bright spot was our waitress Sandy. She was friendly, helpful, and you could tell she was proud of being good at her job.
Drinks were good. Service initially was fine, but everything went downhill after appetizers. Food was brought out and half of the order was incorrect party of 8. The dishes that were brought out were lukewarm at best. The chicken alfredo came with ONE small piece of chicken. See the attached picture of the "Jamaican" chicken sandwich that came with only 5 yes 5 fries. Finally, the other half of the food arrived and there was not a single apology from the waitress. Also, she seemingly disappeared until she brought our check, never asking us if everything was alright clearly it wasn't. Spend your money elsewhere.
We walked in wanting a wine tasting but not knowing what to expect. Our bartender asked what wines we preferred and then chose several for us to try. Everything we sampled, we enjoyed which does not usually happen with a wine tasting. We ended up staying so that I could have a glass of my favorite wine and my boyfriend moved onto trying bourbon that the bartender recommended. It was a fun experience that I would recommend to anyone wanting a quiet hour away from the noisy tourists to relax and unwind.
Todd Allen the owner has done a truly extraordinary job of mixing ambience with truly awe inspiring food..best place in the entire Upper Peninsula of Michigan to eat INCREDIBLE food and drink amazing wine!!!
Had such an amazing experience at Goodfellows thanks to Wally. He brought a great atmosphere to the room, fabulous energy and was incredibly knowledgeable about his wines!! Will definitely be back.
Our group arrived at 6:40p, didn't get to order until 7p and we received our food at 7:54p. The restaurant was almost empty and our waiter only checked on us once. My husband ordered a $35 strip steak medium, which arrived completely raw on the inside. At this point we had waited so long we were going to be late for an event and had to leave without finishing half the steak as he could only force down so much. Unfortunately another member of our group had to leave before food arrived due to their child waiting so long and not having a meal. We travel to the island often and will not be back as this has been our 2nd bad service experience. For the price the food and service leave much to be desired.
Comment on this business

Goodfellows Restaurant map
+−
© OpenStreetMap contributors

to add Goodfellows Restaurant map to your website;



Copyright 2025 | All rights reserved.

You can use our top contact for adding and editing your business's information.
0.0038 Loaded in seconds