Fire Island Rustic Bakeshop

The people here are great! I needed a cake at the last minute & called ahead. By the time I arrived, they had it boxed up, ready to go & even found a way to write Happy Birthday on top! Great job... Much appreciated!
8 years ago (14-12-2017)

The sandwiches and baked goods were superb! I also enjoyed the coffee. The line up and order call over the counter is a bit intimidating for the first time, but I can see how you would be able to get in a groove once you went a couple of times. A daily menu of all the bread, sandwich and salad choices could help when the line is long and you can't peruse the counter ahead of time, but I get how that would be tough to keep up with. All in all, I enjoyed my meal. Price points are a little high, but if you consider the quality of the product, they are actually reasonable. They definitely have a staff of professionals that know their business! So, kudos for that.
8 years ago (06-10-2017)

Amazing for breakfast or lunch. Worth just popping your head in regularly to see what they have. Everything you order will be delicious. Somethings are kind of strange and unique but awesome. If you like rustic, this is the place. A bit pricey, but worth it for the quality food and service. Great for a casual date lunch.
8 years ago (28-09-2017)

This downtown neighborhood bakery offers a creative selection of food items and made to order treats as well as their incredible baked goods. A happy and courteous staff always greets you with full attention, occasionally offering a taste of freshly baked cookies. The french-style macarons are my favorite at the moment. Oh yes, K-Bay coffee with free refills~ I'll stay a while. Also outdoor seating in summer makes this a perfect spot.
8 years ago (10-11-2017)

Wonderful smelling and warm bake some nestled in the downtown suburbs. The bread is tasty, and fairly priced, with a variety of options to choose from. Plenty of seating gives you a great view of the bakers. Has Challah on Fridays if you need it.
8 years ago (28-12-2017)