Amici's Pizzeria

This is one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had!! I ordered a Large pizza with Pepperoni, mushrooms and green olives and 2Lbs of wings for $50. The quality is what counts in why I would agree to pay 50 dollars for a simple thing. Fresh ingredients and the chicken wings don’t get me started. Very very good wings, I would order the wings on their own if I was craving them. Breaded Buffalo is my go too flavour for them! I should’ve looked at the menu better for the same price it shows I could’ve gotten 3Lbs and a large pizza. Now I know for next time when I order again. I recommend this place to everyone in the area. Support local!

I tried Amici’s after the ownership had changed to see how it compares to the original. Amicis has been in Grimsby for decades. I was a bit disappointed to find out of a new owner and changed recipes. I just didn’t want to see another shawarma or gyro style pizza place. They do have that and it’s not good. Gyro is Greek and Shawarma is middle eastern. The gyro is the same spinning coagulated pre-made thing that everyone already has. Stay away. Our pizzas were made fantastic. They had a lot of toppings. The crust is far thicker than the old Amicis so next time I’ll order thinner crust. Stick to the basics and you get a fantastic pizza. The prices are fair and the service is good. I’m not sure why they ask for tips on pick up. This place does it and so does Gino’s. I’m not cheap but come on, I’m picking up my own pizza. You’re not sitting me down for a meal or delivering it to me. I’ll give this place 5 stars and hope they continue to separate themselves from the others. Grimsby is a small town with a lot of pizza places. Gino’s ran king for a long time but competition is catching up. These small guys are better than all the chains generally. There is a bit of difficulty with parking here as you need to go the street beside it to park and grab your pizza. I’d like to see the selection on DoorDash to be similar to what you find online.

I have decided that Amici's pizzeria has the best pizza in Grimsby. Reminds me of a place called fourth man in the fire back in Toronto. The dough was really good. So was the sauce and the toppings. They use red onions which makes the experience so much better. Clearly they know how to make a pizza. The side of garlic sauce was so good. Lots of garlic. This will be my pizza joint. Prices are reasonable too.

Best pizza anywhere! Pino is a genius. Dill pickles on pizza! Love that! The Jay Jones, simple the best creation! Cant wait to order again. Chain restaurants don't taste anything like the quality of Amici's in Grimsby!

The service is friendly, the place is clean and the pizza is delicious. I think it's THE BEST PIZZA in Grimsby! Update: By now I had at least 10 different pizzas from Amici and every single one of them was delicious! I highly recommend this place

I came here for the first time yesterday, it was so good that I came back for lunch today. I got the shawarma wrap made with their amazing homemade bread - the serving was huge and loaded with chicken! I also got their home cut fries - yum! Today I got a panzerotti and it was so big that they gave it to me in a medium size pizza box! It was so big that I asked them to cut it in half - definitely a large enough serving for 2 ppl! The staff was super friendly too - highly recommended!

Ordered the Cajun dry rub with some sauces on the side - and a Hawaiian pizza . The Cajun was awesome, the wings are slightly breaded but still nice and crispy, I personally like mine a little more well done which I’m sure if I ask they would do, and the pizza was good .. nothing fancy about the pizza or unique but was good flavour, will definitely order again :

Amazing pizza, pitas shawarma and gyro, wings and more with great portions. Highly recommend.

Rating this a 3 to give benefit of the doubt. Both our pizzas were soggy and floppy, crust barely cooked pizza near cold after picking up at exact time. Wings were mediocre. Both dips were great. Had high hopes and understand this is a small business so hope to see better of them.

Good it great. But they need to change their hours. They are never there at 12 like google says. Lights are completely off and no one answers. Please update your hours

Directions to Amici's Pizzeria with public transportation

---