facebooktwitterpinterest
mobil menu

Tony Maronni's Pizza

  1. Sussex
  2. Sussex Pizza
  3. Sussex Salad

Reviews, get directions and information for Tony Maronni's Pizza

Tony Maronni's Pizza
"Tony Maronnis dining room will be open when we have enough staff to service our guests, do to labor shortages. Please call and check and make reservations. See you soon"
Address: N63 W23951 Main St , Sussex 53089, WI, US
Phone: +1 262-820-8669
State: WI
City: Sussex
Zip Code: 53089


Opening Hours

Monday: 11:00-20:00
Tuesday: 11:00-20:00
Wednesday: 11:00-20:00
Thursday: 11:00-20:00
Friday: 11:00-21:00
Saturday: 11:00-21:00
Sunday: 11:00-20:00

Update Info

related searches: Sussex pizza, Marcelino's Pizza, Pizza delivery Sussex, Pizza in Sussex, wi, Sussex Bowl menu, Pizza near me, Pizza Menomonee Falls, Thirsty Duck Sussex
Similar places near
Papa Murphy's Papa Murphy's 1 km Prompt and friendly service with a clean environment. The staff seems genuinely happy...
Tj's Pizzeria Cafe Tj's Pizzeria Cafe 1141 km Well this tj’s has really changed since I was a kid. It’s really good. And the staff ...
Lorenzo's Pizzeria and Restaurant Lorenzo's Pizzeria and Restaurant 1141 km Ordered two eggplant dinner take out. Great portions, came with fresh bread and exce...
Annabel Pizza Annabel Pizza 1141 km This place is obviously one of the finest restaurants in the area. Whenever I come th...
Reviews
The english language lacks a sufficient quantity of superlatives to heap into a review of Tony Maronni's restaurant. I was in the area for a work project that required about 2-3 hours of down time spent waiting. I had missed lunch to drive for the project. I was recommended to here. My order was fairly straight forward. An order of mozzarella sticks and a small thin crust cheese, pepperoni and sausage pizza. My expectations for the mozzarella sticks were your standard string cheese coated in some breading. Never in my wildest imagination was I expecting what appeared at my table. Easily 2" in diameter and 6-7" long. They were made with fresh dough as the wrapping and fresh mozzarella in such quantity as to make this son of Wisconsin experience a dairy Nirvana. My pizza could only be described as close to perfection as I have ever eaten. An amazing dough turned into an amazing crust. The same fresh mozzarella. The meats and spices blended to create a desire to invest in genetic modifcation... a second stomach is the only thing that could have made this meal better. It was slow, as I was there in the mid-afternoon. I had the opportunity to hear Tony's history about how the restaurant came to be. 17 years it has been. I live a a small city that is known for its pizzerias. Some of them are very, very good. When I am out of town, I use them as bragging rights. I can no longer in good faith espouse my home town pizza. I will sing the praises of this small town pizzeria going forward. Thank you, Tony for the absolute best pizza experience I have ever had. Hats off and kudos to you.
My roommate and I love this place for pizza however, we decided to dine in tonight and my roommate got the spaghetti. We waited 40 minutes for my pizza and her spaghetti, my pizza and very few toppings and her spaghetti came out cold, with barely any sauce. We sent it back and the server returned the plate after telling us they put it in the microwave and added more sauce. It wasn’t much better flavor wise. I took a bite of her meatball and IMMEDIATELY spit it out on my plate. I will forever be haunted by the texture. It was like wet bread. The server was amazing and so sweet but we will never get the pasta here again. On top of the terrible spaghetti, we only had a few dollars taken off the bill for the terrible pasta.
Frozen spinach I’ve never seen that on pizza. Extra fees for a credit card Garlic bread might be frozen They just added oregano on there do not recommend for garlic bread and spinach
I'm visiting from out of state and had no expectations on what type of pizza place I was in for. Purchased the large 16" margarita pizza with hand tossed crust and WOW! Dare I say this was one of the best margarita pizzas I have ever eaten. Sauce was 10/10 outstanding, crust was delicious, cheese was generously portioned without being overwhelming and melted perfectly, and toppings and seasonings were right on point. The only reason I haven't attached a picture of this beautiful pie was that we devoured it too quickly. Although the pizza was a bit higher priced than competing places, it was sizeable, so delicious, filling, and the ingredients were so fresh I didn't mind paying a bit more for taste and quality. When I come back to the area there's no question in my mind that I'll be returning to Tony Maronni's!
I've been here before and the pizza was decent. I got a coupon in the mail so my wife and I ordered a pizza today. It was so hard I couldn't even chew the crust. Seems like they must have burnt it. Any other day I would've taken it right back, but we were so hungry we decided we'd try to deal with it. We literally had 1 piece and had to give up. Super disappointed because I could've probably gotten 2 pizzas from dominos or something for the same price.
It's good pizza and great service! It's a pinch from being a great pizza just cuz its missing one or 2 spices that I cant pin down.
Husband had pizza which he said was good. I had spaghetti and meatball. Meatball tasted raw.sauce was extremely salty .
Pizza was pretty good. WAY too much oregano or some kind of Italian spice. Also not enough sauce on either pizza.Food: 3/5
Always fresh, hot and incredibly delicious. It might cost a little bit more than others, but hands down, the best pizza and well worth it. The hand tossed crust is our favorite.
Excellent pizza! Nice little dining area. Gluten Freeno promises though. I didn't have a reaction pizza is deelish.Food: 5/5
Comment on this business

Tony Maronni's Pizza map

to add Tony Maronni's Pizza map to your website;



Copyright 2025 | All rights reserved.

You can use our top contact for adding and editing your business's information.
0.0032 Loaded in seconds