Pizza Shop

Such a great spot to have decent pizza. The sandwich selection is good but the food is lacking in flavor, kinda blah. This place has the potential to become something great but in it's current food iteration it is not amazing. The decor and location are great. Enjoy your food as freight trains go by and take in the mountain view that is unfortunately blocked by trees. Ok maybe it's not so ideal but it's still a cool looking pizza,spot.
7 years ago (26-11-2017)

Pretty good pizza. Some pretty interesting pies. Try the Notorious P.I.G. though I think they left it in too long and the edges got burnt- that citrus chipotle sauce is on point! The service is good too.
7 years ago (01-12-2017)

Love it here...I get delicious food and fast service... and nice comfortable setting inside and out. The salads are delicious and the variety of pizzas.... Love the pulled pork pizza, margarita pizza and their vegetable pizzas... their cranberry walnut salad is my favorite with or without chicken.... my favorite spot in Newburgh!
7 years ago (27-09-2017)

Good subs and pizza slices. Thin crust brick oven style pizza. Good quality ingredients and fresh made food. Chicken cutlets are actually handmade and not "out of the box". Impressive selection of pies and other Italian American favorites. Service was fast and friendly. Pricing is reasonable. The building is beautiful and a former train station.
7 years ago (06-09-2017)

We had a great time at the Pizza Shop. The food was awesome as always. I was just a little disappointed that they didn’t have pasta fagioli soup. When I asked the waitress when they started making soup again she said October. Funny thing, it was already October 13 and no soup. ☹️. I actually think October is a little late to start making soup in New York. It starts getting cool in late August.
7 years ago (14-10-2017)