Stella's Pizzeria

Stella's is by far the best pizza in Newburgh. Frank has maintained the quality of the pizza since the beginning. I'm here visiting from Florida and this is the only place I will eat pizza. Highly recommend eating here. Look forward to my next visit. Friendly and courteous staff.
8 years ago (06-12-2017)

I'm not writing home to anyone about this slice of pie. It does its job, perhaps a bit overpriced, but it's a reasonable good slice. I think they need to sell their slices for less than two bucks and I'd feel great about price and value. This will not be your favorite pizza spot but it is reliable, clean and has a friendly staff that keeps the place safe and clean
8 years ago (06-12-2017)

On March 3,2017, my co-worker and I ordered a large cheese pie to be delivered to our job. My co-worker was VERY specific about where to deliver it. Well... the man that came to deliver the pizza pulled up and had a female in the car. They were BOTH SMOKING cigarettes. The guy pulled the pizza out of the car and it appeared to be sitting on the seat instead of a pizza sleeve! When we called to talk to Frank, we told him what happened and told him we threw out the pizza. He apologized and said he would give us 10% off our next visit! REALLY?! We could not eat the pizza and did not have time to order more food because our break was over. To add insult to injury we went there today 3/20/2017. We ordered 2 slices each. My co-worker asked to talk to him. He never came over but he did keep looking at us! When we went to pay he sent his pizza maker, Juan, to "deal" with the situation instead of talking to us himself. What happened to being grateful for customers who are nice?! WOW!!! NEVER AGAIN!!! A. Rodriguez
8 years ago (20-03-2017)

Grew up on this pizza. Great toppings and has fried dough.
8 years ago (19-11-2017)

Nothing out of ordinary. Big slices though!
8 years ago (07-12-2017)