facebooktwitterpinterest
mobil menu

Peter Sciortino's Bakery

  1. Milwaukee
  2. Milwaukee Bakeries

Reviews, get directions and information for Peter Sciortino's Bakery

Peter Sciortino's Bakery
"Serving the Milwaukee metropolitan area for over 70 years. We specialize in Italian Breads, rolls, cookies and pastries. We no longer make our cakes in house. We recommend either Aggie's Bakery or Scordato Bakery for any Cake needs.Due to staff shortages in all departments, please allow at least 48 hours in advance for larger orders.Visit our website for shipping options, we always ship priority mail but please keep in mind that with shortages in the shipping industry, packages may not arrive when expectedonce we send the package it is out of our control."
Address: 1101 E Brady St , Milwaukee 53202, WI, US
Phone: +1 414-272-4623
State: WI
City: Milwaukee
Zip Code: 53202


Opening Hours

Tuesday: 07:00-16:00
Wednesday: 07:00-16:00
Thursday: 07:00-16:00
Friday: 07:00-16:00
Saturday: 07:00-16:00
Sunday: 07:00-13:00

Update Info

related searches: Scardino's Bakery, Pete's Bakery Milwaukee WI, Italian Bakery Milwaukee, Scordato Bakery, Canfora Bakery menu, French bakery Milwaukee, National Bakery Milwaukee, Mini pastries Milwaukee
Similar places near
Metro Market Metro Market 595 miles The store is always clean, easy to navigate and I love the veggie sushi roll. Every t...
Classy Girl Cupcakes Classy Girl Cupcakes 1 km The cake Monsters, Inc and mini cupcakes were a huge hit at my daughter’s baby shower...
Blooming Lotus Bakery Blooming Lotus Bakery 1 km Thanksgiving ordering and pick up was very easy and quick. The pumpkin pie was the be...
Insomnia Cookies Insomnia Cookies 2 km
Fiddleheads Coffee Fiddleheads Coffee 2 km Great cinnamon roll. No picture because I ate it too fast! Coffee was "meh"...
MATC Bakery MATC Bakery 2 km
Breadsmith Milwaukee Public Market Breadsmith Milwaukee Public Market 2 km It's fresh bread, what's not to like? Buy a loaf of sourdough, makes some toast with ...
C Adam's Bakery C Adam's Bakery 2 km Really good bakery, located in the milwaukee public square so you can grab a treat wh...
Compassionate Cake Compassionate Cake 2 km
Greige Patisserie Greige Patisserie 3 km We love this place. Visited for the first time and loved their assortment of sweet tr...
Blooming Lotus Bakery Blooming Lotus Bakery 4 km Lovely place with amazing treats - both GF and Vegan They went out of their way to m...
Reynold's Pasty Shop Reynold's Pasty Shop 5 km Onions and carrots were really spicy...Other than that it was worth it
Todo Postres Todo Postres 7 km They are pretty good at what they do here. Havent been here before but ill definitely...
Attari Supermarket Attari Supermarket 8 km Went here looking for baklava and bought a few other things including coffee and pita...
Manhattan Mocha Cafe Manhattan Mocha Cafe 10 km Tried a variety of frappes and they were all delicious. The Oreo, Carmel and white ch...
French Bakery French Bakery 12 km
Valentine Coffee Valentine Coffee 12 km Very nice coffee shop. Good atmosphere. Very nice workers.
French Meadow Cafe French Meadow Cafe 12 km Nice place , it’s located in concourse C as you go past security
Reviews
Stumbled upon this place when I was exploring the neighborhood. Everything looks delicious. I got an assortment of cookies 9.95 as well as the banana split cupcake, about 5 bucks. I was a little disappointed because although it had a good flavor, it was dry. I read other reviews about this issue, as well as the response from the owners. Seems like there is no resolve about this. The creme topping that was used had a great texture and was delicious however. The cookie assortment was delicious. The texture and how it melts in your mouth will bring me back. I will try the cupcakes again, but go when the store first opens to see if there is a difference.
The almond croissant was good, but the nutella croissant is absolutely delicious!!! Of course the cookies were fantastic, as always.
I have been coming here ever since I was a child. I love everything about this place from the bread to the cookies. Customer service has always been great and the consistency of everything makes it that much better. I will continue to come back for years to come.
The customer service was great. My friend and I bought holiday cookies and eclair. The eclair and cookies did not taste as fresh as I expected. We had to waste the products we brought because it was not edible. They tasted like they’ve been sitting out for days.
First time coming in. The atmosphere was friendly and welcoming. Very informative on all the fresh baked goods in shop. Cashier was a male, incredibly kind. Walked in to buy 2 small baked goods a friend let me try, and walked out with 35$ of new things to tey with my boyfriend. Beyond excited for how fresh and fantastic it all looks! I cannot wait. Thank you guys so all your hard work and love that gets put into these. I notice it!
Based on the reviews here, I had high expectations for this place and I’m sad to say it did not meet any of them. I got the Turtle cupcake, chocolate hazelnut filled cone, and the very berry cake. The cupcake frosting was good, but the cake itself was SO dry like inedible dry. The cone was okay, the pastry had a nutty taste to it like it was made with almond extract ? and the filling was overly sweet. The very berry cake was decent, but the crust was soggy. I was hoping this bakery would be a new go-to for me, but I don’t think I’ll be going back.
Cute Italian bakery with everything your heart needs. From breads to rolls to deli items, this place has it. Went in looking for Lobster rolls pics below and left with a little extra. The employees are friendly and welcoming. The prices are reasonable and of course the baked goods do not disappoint!
I'm sure that at one time, this bakery was pretty good. I suppose it still is if you think Dunkin' Donuts has good baked stuff. This place has gone the way of so many places where they've pushed to quality to the edge of what's acceptable. I imagine some stuff is good, but the paczkis we ordered in advance and picked up at 10 am on Fat Tuesday were just barely ok. The chocolate bavarian creme paczki I just ate tasted a bit stale. Either that, or they tried to make it taste like cardboard. What the heck?
I finally stopped in today to try some of these delicious sweets. I ended up ordering a three layer cake and loved it. I'd love to come back. @dietproof
My FAVORITE family-owned neighborhood bakery. The cannolis are assembled fresh and are so cheap & yummy. Must visit!!
Comment on this business

Peter Sciortino's Bakery map

to add Peter Sciortino's Bakery map to your website;



Copyright 2025 | All rights reserved.

You can use our top contact for adding and editing your business's information.
0.0106 Loaded in seconds