Old Town Pizza

Drove by this place and decided to grab a pizza from here for family dinner Friday. So glad I did! The thin crust veggie was amazing. Perfect balance of cheese to sauce ratio. Would totally go back!!

Easily one of the best pizzas my family and I have ever had. This place is our go to! We like to keep it simple with a thin crust cheese pizza with extra cheese, and the crust never gives in. Always nice and crunchy, and the sauce and seasoning is delightful.

I’ve been coming here for over a decade. I was worried the pandemic would take out this small business but luckily the pizza is so good they are still thriving. I sadly no longer live in the area but every time I’m back to see family and friends I make sure to grab a slice or two. Giardiniera slices are available on Monday’s, my favorite, but no matter the slice you will not regret it.

UPDATE: I have updated this rating because of the amazing customer service I just experienced. Owner actually called me and he refunded me the entire price of the pizza! In this day and age, its awesome to find such amazing customer service. The owner, Joe, was very kind and explained that they will try communicating to newer customers about what to expect for this particular type of pizza. These are the type of business owner I like to support. Thank you Joe! If I do order from here again, I probably will be getting the thin crust pizza, Original Review: Got an XL deep dish pizza with spinach. Very little pizza sauce and excessive amounts of cheese. I actually saw reviews from other customers that complained about there being excessive cheese in the deep dish pizza and not enough sauce. I am glad I am not the only one who noticed this. I actually had to add my own sauce to make it bearable. Overall, I was very disappointed. The only good part was the crust.

I ordered a large Italian beef pizza for the Super Bowl and it was great! Would definitely recommend!

Decided to get a couple of of pizzas because of a friend's recomdation...so glad I did! Their cheese is is A M A Z I N G!!! Thanks OTP

I didn't like their Sicilian pizza... got pepperoni couldn't taste it through the rest of it. There wasn't a balance between toppings and cheese. Maybe we could of added more toppings but we have done this before and never has been an issue. I also had the beer nuggets didn't taste like anything the outside of them were nice and toasty, but the sauce taste like water and not thick enough to dip the nuggets in. I'm a fattie, can't remember when was the last time I was disappointed about pizza.

Meh. Our kids loved their heart-shaped personal pizzas. My wife and I were disappointed in our thin crust sausage. Very light on the sausage and VERY salty. Maybe there are supply chain issues with sausage now too but apparently not salt? Lots of other positive reviews, so maybe an off night for them, but for our money, there are better spots elsewhere in town. Features: None; guy at the counter was unmasked as was the cook in back.

The food was quite good. I had the panzerotti. Not as good as Grotto's in Waukesha but still good. The pizza was good. I love places that have hot giardiniera as a topping. Prices are comparable to others. All the pizza on the menu looks good, so I may have to try a Chicago style or double dough pizza soon.Dine in: NoOutdoor seating: NoTakeout: YesDelivery: Yes

Now the food itself is good, but we ordered one gluten free pizza and 1 regular and they were both regular, but one was labeled as gluten free when it wasn’t. My sister ate the pizza thinking that it was gluten free because it was labeled as such, but it was not and she got very sick from it. It’s important to follow through with labeling- especially when people have allergies like Celiac!! : UPDATE: they reached out and handled the situation very responsibly. We were refunded the order and they made everything right! Thank you for helping us and sorting out the situation! Updated and added 2 more stars bc of their response. :