Harvest & Hearth

Made a reservation on Wednesday afternoon for a party of 5 on Friday at 7pm as part of a birthday celebration. Drove an hour to the restaurant to be told by the hostess that our name wasn't on the list. She made no attempt to check if our name was copied down wrong, no attempt to rectify the situation in any way, didn't even apologize, and had the nerve to tell us that we could get a table if we waited for over an hour. They lost our reservation and then made us wait OVER AN HOUR to be seated. There's nothing nearby and it was Travers weekend so there was no way we could really go anywhere else. When I pressed a second hostess to check if our name was copied down wrong or anything she (who said she was new, and apologetic at least so no hard feelings towards her) said that they don't even take reservations for parties less than 7... so who took our reservation Wednesday!? we were finally seated and we weren't offered any sort of compensation or apology for the wait. Nothing. We ended up not leaving the restaurant until almost 10 o'clock which effectively ruined the rest of the night we had planned as our next destination was closed by the time we arrived. Our waitress was nice at least, but the pizza genuinely wasn't particularly good. The crust was almost TOO thin, and the sauce was honestly kind of gross. Cheeses and toppings were just kind of... there. The salads, however, were good salads. Drinks were overpriced and the one round we had ended up being almost half our bill for just beers, some of which were only domestic. The cost of a small pizza is only a dollar less than a large and it's quite literally tiny. Fit for maybe a child and that's it. I'd say the large pizzas are priced appropriately for the size but not for the taste. The aesthetic of the whole place feels sort of... unfilled and unwelcoming. I guess the bar is sort of nice as far as bar tops go, but don't expect a water view because all you're getting is kayak racks. Overall the food experience was mediocre and the pricing was mediocre, but coupled with the worst service I've ever received from a hostess I can't reasonably recommend this restaurant to anyone. I've spent my entire life in the area and I would recommend literally anywhere else. I'll give it a 2 because I'm sure the kitchen staff and other wait staff were doing their best and they don't deserve a 1 for that.
9 years ago (26-08-2017)

Some of the best pizza we've ever had. The atmosphere is great and the staff are very friendly and welcoming. The location by the water is pretty neat too. Definitely coming back and bringing friends.
9 years ago (18-07-2017)

Not sure what happened tonight but I ordered 2 small pies at 501pm and a poppy salad, pies were ready at 615pm and poppy salad was ready at 640pm , won't be ordering takeout again!
8 years ago (24-09-2017)

Delicious wood fired pizzas and a warm atmosphere. A fun dinner.
9 years ago (07-09-2017)

Pizza was terrible. Nice cozy place. Just beer and wine. Great potential though. Plenty of parking. Owners need to regroup a g make changes.
9 years ago (06-08-2017)