Faye's Pizza

Amazing!! I like pizza, but I really love Faye's pizza. Never had a bad one. Try them. If you like everything on it - try the Deluxe. Price is reasonable.

It's a perfectly fine place to get a pizza. It was delivered hot, quickly, and our order was correct. The crust was really nice but the sauce and cheese didn't really taste like much. It was kind of bland. But, I'm not mad I ordered it. There's better in town, but this pizza is acceptable.

We asked some friends for their pizza recommendation in the area and their unanimous recommendation was for Faye's -- and they were spot on! Servers were friendly and knowledgeable and the food was amazing. You owe it to yourself to try the sausage, which is made fresh at Miesfeld's.

The Faye's house deluxe pizza was really really good but there BLT pizza just didn't seem to be as good as last time I got it, but still good.

Excellent pizza place in Sheboygan. Their crust is fantastic. It's light and crispy without being flimsy. I had the Faye's house deluxe large and ate almost two thirds of it myself. Service is good too. Highly recommend

This place is straight up amazing! Everything we ordered was delicious! Staff was friendly. Highly recommend to eat here!

Brings back fond memories of when we first came to Howard's Grove. Food was great. Service was a bit slow but my companion and I did enjoy our garlic bread. The toppings were generous. The pizza sauce with not overwhelming. Nice place to visit.

Best pizza you will find in Sheboygan County and quite frankly anywhere else. I took real Wisconsin cheese for granted until I moved to Florida 13 years ago. Faye's has the best ingredients and their thin crust is unrivaled. They are consistently voted the best pizza in Sheboygan for a reason.

They have awesome pizza. When we order pizza we always go here.