Eataliano Kitchen

Loved it. It seemed pricy at first but the value proposition was excellent. Nice, clean, quiet when we went good enough service considering she was alone customer facing side for the 5 tables with customers. Covid vaccinations were checked, distance between tables were thought out. Recommended! The picture depicts the superfood salad with an extra side of pan fried tofu front left, yams fries on the right, the middle plate was the garlic toast that came with the salad and the last plate was the baked pasta penne with meat sauce that also came with garlic toast. Picture of the chocolate ecstasy which was surprisingly not overly sweet. Don't get me wrong, its chocolate cake sweet but not fudge dumped in nesquick sweet and carrot cake that was hard. We couldn't tell if it was hard due to gluten free flour or had just dried out in the fridge.

Frist impressions of your restaurant, wasn't the greatest, very slow service, had a 30 minute wait for food, even before that I over heard other customers got free stuff because they're orders were messed up. When we got home, to check the pizza it was under cooked, raw dough as you can see in the pics below, we had to recook ours so it was eatable, and it still just tasted like a frozen pizza barley good, I think it needed more veggies, I believe you don't have many vegetarian/Vegan options. I know it was your opening day but it was laking in so many ways, to be honest I only went for the sale and that you were new and in a place where we don't have much restaurants. Not sure if I'll ever check it out again, because you didn't own up to it when my mom contacted you guys, whom ever does the FB page needs better customer service. If a friend asks to get pizza in Cedar we'll get it from the wheatsheaf pub or from Robert's Street pizza. All I hope is you do better and actually own up to having horrible food and don't blame the customers for giving feedback.

Seriously disappointed & super inconsistent! Heard this new restaurant got a lot of negativity over social media, but my parents & I decided to give our new local restaurant a try. Our first server was awesome, she gave wonderful service & made our some killer drinks, but when she was off work & our other service took over we really noticed! Our second round of drinks were awful, very watered down and flavorless. We were ignored until our food arrived; I ordered a crispy chicken burger with yam fries. Both my parents order the steak sandwich; my mom with ceasar salad & my dad with fries & gravy. My dad also ordered a extra side of onion rings after raving to our server about how amazing they were the last time! As we started to eat I noticed that istead of a breaded chicken breast i had two chicken strips in my burger & the yam fries came with cheese dip instead of the regular chipotle mayo, which I personally didn't like at all. My mom & dad both had different cuts of steak, but moms was thicker & was cooked to a perfect medium-rare. My dad's was the real shocking disappointment, it seemed to be that they cut the steak down the middle to open it up so it seemed bigger but was sooo over cooked you could barely cut threw it & to top it off they forgot it onion rings. As he was very turned off after as we all were, he got the onion rings made to-go & had to send his steak back due to how over cooked it was and didn't want another one I wish i remembered to take a picture it looked gross. As we paid up & were waiting for our onion rings to go the server noticed she forgot to charge us for our drinks & of course we paid for them but the attitude she gave us was even more disappointing, was way more worried about money than giving good service & food. As we got home my dad open the container of onions & was shocked! They literally charged us $16 for 8 pitiful onion rings! He said it himself he will NEVER eat there again, you only get one chance with him & i feel the same way! CONSISTENCY IS KEY. Especially in a small town like Cedar you'll either make it or break it. We wont be back.

Absolutely excellent. Very welcoming and accommodating owners. Quite honestly best pizza I've had on the island in sometime. Pizza crust second to none.

I love this restaurant! The menu is diverse and the price is reasonable. The "in dining" has been shut down staffing issues, but they let us dine in for my 60th birthday dinner. I love the community feeling of doing that for us. Thank you Food: 5/5

Absolutely amazing food! I had a couple pizzas, cheesebread and im definitely going to be back for more! I placed my order before the dinner rush and it was ready and smelled delicious at the time I requested! The new renovations look amazing, I cant wait until dine-in is an option! Cedar needed this new restaurant and I'm so glad its here!

I’ve dined here with my wife and friends several times. The server was the same every time as it just so happenedthe owner. Very welcoming and pleasant. She and her husband recently started and are doing a perfect job! The food was really exceptional every time. I really commend them for their efforts. We have to as customers appreciate these entrepreneurs Working through such challenging circumstances as of late. We have family visiting and was really looking forward to taking them there for my favourite dishbutter chicken lasagna wow but saw they were Closed temporarily. We wish you the best and hope to see you soon. Ron.

Pizza is so good So happy you’re back open. Thank you so much. Ordered our favourite pizzas and to my surprise the owner walked me and my son to my car, carrying my order for me as my back is a mess from a car accident. So thoughtful, thank you. His wife is so sweet as well. Thank you both. See you again soon

Jeeez that Carne Fantastico pizza was delicious!! The marinara sauce was really good, the different meats. Will definitely go back! I have found the best pizza on the island!

The staff were great! Not a big fan of the pizza sauce, because it was neopolitan style which didn't match the rest of the pizza, but the pizza was really well made. Check it out...Food: 2/5