Casey's General Store

Ordered pizza box meal. Pizza was so cold! Wings were cold! Breadsticks burnt! Plus I had to wait 2 hours for it to be made because they only had one cook and they needed to take a break. All that waiting for disappointing pricey pizza. So I called to complain. Got a replacement order that was the same disaster as the first! I watched them for 30-40 minutes because again they fell behind on orders. They had already made my pizza 15 minutes before they put my wings in the oven. It was just there on the table getting cold. Never ever ever will i eat at Gaylords Casey's pizza! The worst worst team ever. Would give it a zero if possible.
8 years ago (25-10-2017)

The place is great since they expanded. It was okay before, but now they have ice cream. The staff is helpful and nice.
8 years ago (26-07-2017)

They just got a facelift inside so now they have a true deli type feel. Always really good pizza. Prices are so so, a little expensive maybe when buying a fresh wrap or chicken but it works when you're on the go. Order pizza ahead of time tho, especially at dinner time. This place gets really busy.
8 years ago (29-05-2017)

Awesome store remodel. Fresher food and friendly workers.
8 years ago (04-07-2017)

Horrible!! Spent $60 on Pizza and they couldn't even take the order. Had to go there as they don't hang up the phone . . . asked me to hold then forget about me . . . locals say it happens all the time. . . I won't do it again. . . Horrible service. Manager was supposed to call me the next morning and she is too lazy (they said she wouldn't) and she didn't! Very poor management, one star is too good.
8 years ago (05-06-2017)