Cara Mia's Pizzeria

While the food is solid, the prices are outrageous for what you get. A large Caeser salad is $17 when the ingredients can’t cost more than $5-$7 dollars. It’s quite small for the price. A large pizza with 3 toppings will cost over $30 dollars. Like I said the food is good, but the price point is too much. All I can hope is that the marked up prices are because they pay their employees well. If not, then shame on cara Mia’s.

BAD BUSINESS!!!!!!Ordered a overpriced large pie for pick up and told my total was 17.60.When trying to pay for it my total came to 18.25 .when I asked why I was informed at the register it because I wasn't paying cash which clearly states it's all about dodging the IRS . Told my order would be done in 30 min ..showed up in 20 to pick up a coagulated pile of cold cheese on undercooked dough.There was more sugar in the tomato sauce than I get in my glass of chocolate milk at the end of the night.. to all visitors or anybody that values their dollar. There's only one place to get pizza within 20 mi of Rutland and that is iPie in Killington. If not, I highly suggest you get a box of elio's from the supermarket cuz it will taste exactly the same as any pie you can get in Rutland. SKETCHY BUSINESS PRACTICES GUY .DISHONEST MENU PRICES. I can only assume you're extremely lucky cuz the IRS is completely backed up in paperwork.. and that my friends is my 65 cents of input

What on earth is wrong with their delivery driver? While working I order a Pizza. We only have 15 minute breaks so its a tight window for pickup. Cara Mia's quotes 12:15pm for me to pick the pizza up out front of my work. I get out there at 12:14 and the pizza guy is driving away. The guard informs me that he had been there for 5 mins waiting. No phone call to let me know he was early. Gone before the quoted time. Now he wants to drive around town delivering everyone else's pizza and bring me my cold one about the time I'm supposed to be back in working. Unbelievable. We give a lot of business to Cara Mia's but I'm about to spread the word of how terrible this customer service is. Who leaves before the time they quoted? Why no phone call that they were early? I'll never order from this place again. 100% completely awful. That driver should be fired. How can anyone allow such horrible service?

I ordered a pizza from this place literally got delivered about 10 minutes ago. Politely asked them to put napkins and plates in with the order, didn't do it. Also they didn't even cut the pizza. They just left it whole. The lady who took the order was actually nice I don't know what the staff is up to there at that place but they need to get it together because now you guys just lost business. There is other pizza places in Rutland Vermont like ramunto's and Olympic Pizza and there's a few others. Business will definitely go to them sorry Cara mias but you guys dropped the ball won't be calling you back. And I live in Rutland Vermont.

Have enjoyed everything ordered from Cara Mia's! Great delivery and staff! Highly recommend! Love the New York style pizza!

We ordered pizza for delivery while staying at the Paw House Inn nearby. The pizza came very quickly. We ordered the everything pizza which had sausages, pepperoni, meatball and veggies. It was very tasty!

We ordered a small pizza and in order of chicken wings. The wings were still raw and I had to finish cooking them at home and add flavor. It cost almost $ 35.00 for only these 2 items. They were not cooked and flavorless.Plus the bottom of the pizza was dry and burnt in sections. I paid them to have to cook the wings myself at home. Don’t waste your time nor money.

Used to be great and sometimes still is but last 3 times we ordered the order was not only incorrect but the pasta was burnt to a crisp, subs were made wrong and the salad was missing.

Spent $45.90 for raw wings, bland pizza and terrible customer service. It was my first time and last time ordering from them. Do not waste your time and just go to Ramunto's. At least their food is better and they care about their customers, unlike Cara Mia's.

Not great pizza. Wouldn't have come back if Ramuntos wasn't closes. Get here on time and the ticket wasn't put in and pizza not even started. So I waited. And they didn't even take anything off the bill for it or offer any sort of apology.