Surf Lodge and Pub

Nice spot. Good food, good service. Great views. Not formulaic.
8 years ago (24-03-2018)

We had dinner in the dining room which desperately needs updating. The restaurant had a strange smell, musty with a hint of cat lady? I think the carpet was the main source of the odd smells. I highly recommend management consider ripping out the carpet and replacing with a wood floor of some sort, that's really what the place needs the most. The antique decor does add interest and the building is log (maybe, inside anyways) which adds a nice element. Although we didn't witness one, this is a great place to have a refreshing beverage and watch a sunset view. Our dinner was good, but our halibut was over cooked which was disappointing. The wait staff was marvelous though, quite attentive, probably due to it being a slow season and us being 1 of 3 parties having dinner. Overall this isn't a bad place to have a meal once one is accustomed to the strange smell and the outdated carpet.
9 years ago (19-09-2017)

Super friendly and accommodating staff, and the place is just full of character. The wood finish and that lodge feel are just spot on. I can just imagine staying here during the summer months when the weather is sunny and warm! Must be a treat. Although I have to admit the fireplace smell in the main dining area was definetly a big plus in my books so one good reason to be here on colder days. I love that smell. Plus the aged wood just looks spectacular. Also the food here is great. Those chicken wings were some of the best I have had! Also Brunch was great. Just wish they had breakfast every day with how tastey it was
9 years ago (10-12-2017)

A very quaint place across the road from the beach. Beautiful views of the water. They have a few separate cabins which are pet friendly. Restaurant has good food and outdoor patio. Staff are very friendly and accommodating. There is no air conditioning, so Summer nights are very warm. Normal for the island.
9 years ago (06-09-2017)

A beautiful location with sea views, rustic decor, and excellent menu. Service friendly and good. Reservations recommended.
9 years ago (14-10-2017)