Prohibition Bistro

Our first time at this fabulous restaurant. My husband got the special, which included the mussels, and they were phenomenal! I had a special order of pasta Alfredo and it was honestly THE BEST pasta I have ever had at any restaurant. After mentioning to our waitress, Brianna, that we really enjoyed the mussels, we were personally thanked by the owner.
7 years ago (11-11-2017)

Went here on a glowing recommendation. My expectations were more than surpassed, and they were high. The decor is great. The staff was fantastic. The food is wonderful. It is pricey for Sheboygan but it is well worth it. I highly recommend. I will add, if you think this is a Pizza Ranch type place, it isn't. It is a real restaurant with real drinks, appetizers and pizzas/entrees and desserts.
7 years ago (07-10-2017)

I've been to this place a couple of times. The first time the food was not that good, but at the time it was a new restaurant so I thought it would take time. So tried it again tonight. The service is great as the staff are very helpful and are definitely great. Unfortunately you can't say the same about the food. My expectations may be a little high as this is the same family that brought you Harry's Diner, which has amazing food (highly recommend). The beer selection is poor. You can expect over priced cheap beer brands mostly. Pretty generic and nothing to write home about. It would seem the food has gotten much worse since the first time I tried Prohibition Bistro. The pizza (one of their signature dishes) tasted a bit burnt. The mussels and shrimp linguini was cold, and even the kids snubbed their meals (takes a lot to get kids to pass on pasta). I am really trying to think of something good to say because I think even the worst restaurant can have something positive. I don't have any axe to grind. You know those folks that always are overly critical of everything? I don't want to come off as one of those, because I really do support our local places. Unfortunately, other than the service, I can't really say anything good about Prohibition Bistro. Because ultimately it's all about the food and it's just plain bad.
7 years ago (10-11-2017)

What can I say if you're in Sheboygan there's no better place for authentic Neapolitan pizza and Pasta. Wine selection is on point and many beer options too. Good service, and the atmosphere is just..... gotta check it out for your self!!
7 years ago (09-11-2017)

Wonderful experience on 3 occasions so far. The food is outstanding, the service is always quick, attentive, and friendly. The pricing is a little above average but you get what you pay for. Would not hesitate to recommend. The brick oven cooked artisan pizzas are to die for.
7 years ago (01-07-2017)