Pizza On Fire

Been coming to this hidden gem regularly to get my pizza cravings fix. The pizza have is amazing. They are very generous with the toppings. The flavour is amazing compared to other pizza places in town. You can tell they make their dough fresh and only use the best ingredients. I've tried their wings a while ago and it's alright for what it is. Will get their pasta next time around and write another review... For the location, they're found right across the Highland Farms. They are a bit hidden but once you know, you know. Aside from the pizza, the people who work there or owners? are the nicest people ever. You can tell they're very passionate about their business. I highly highly recommend you to give this place a try if you like pizza.

The owner/cook/cashier was super friendly. The place was tiny with one small square table and two chairs. It appears to be a pizza takeout/delivery place. Ordered their Philly steak pizza. The dough and the ingredients were fresh. The toppings were generous. It was pretty tasty, a little oily though, the crust was a little too soft to my liking. The place could use some tidy up.

Had an offer from Ubereats that I couldn’t resist. I have also been wanting to try this independent family-owned pizza place for a while. Read lots of great reviews and now I know why. Next time I will order direct to support this small business. Their pizzas are AMAZING, loaded with so much toppings. • Hawaiian - Small - thin crust • Tandoori - Medium - regular crust - well done. This is spicy for me but it’s really good. I have to visit the store soon. The staff on the phone was very nice and helpful. Can’t wait to meet her in person!

This was good pizza and everything tasted great. If you’re not into heavy pizza like deep dish this won’t be your favourite but my pizza was very tasty. Would definitely recommend you give it a try. My only negative would be a little more well done on the bottom. It might be a balance as well since the top has so many toppings. Either way it was really good.

The best pizza joint in Scarborough without a doubt! Small family run business with amazing quality pizza and friendly service. You will pay more than chain pizza restaurants, but it is completely worth it and you can see and taste the difference. We always ask for well done pizza which is cooked perfectly. My picky father who doesn't eat pizza will only eat the pizza from Pizza on Fire. Highly recommend trying their classic or gourmet pizzas

The pizzas are really good tasting! And the owner is so nice, they informed us they didn’t have bacon, so they added extra sausage for us! Good service and delicious food the taste is very similar to pizza I tried in China!

Definitely one of the best pizzas I had. I enjoyed everything about the pizza. The dough, the cheese, the perfectly cooked toppings. Even the service, my friends and I were waiting outside in the parking lot and they brought the pizza to us. I would definitely come back here again.

I have to say this really could be the best pizza in Scarborough. The crust is so light and crispy. The toppings are the best around, real sausage and delicious stringy cheese. The pizza looked small for an XL but was so rich, so much toppings and flavour, incredible. The sauce is a little on the light side. The cheese is the star here, so good. It’s hard to get your mind blown by a pizza, but this comes close. The wings are very good. I think it’s called Tempura style, I have similar wings anytime I go to a Chinese restaurant or Mandarin. So crispy and cooked perfect. Maybe not the best wings I ever had but top 10. They staff are super nice and friendly. It’s like you’ve been going there your whole life on your first visit. Thanks for the brownies, super delicious and moist. For the money I spent $62 on an xl pizza and 20 wings and was super happy with the value. If you order from Pizza Nova it will cost $10 more and you will get half as much. Cheeper pizza places now feel like cardboard, ketchup and processed cheese. This is my go to place from now on.

Simply loved it! Found this place through UberEats and decided to try their Halal Tandoori Chicken pizza. Both my partner and I fell in love at our first bite itself. The ingredients were first class and the flavor was on point ! Would love to try their BBQ next

Found out my neighbour gets his pizzas from here so I figured I'd give it a shot. I gotta say, they do not disappoint. Picked up a couple of the walk-in specials and some wings for the family and we found it to be delicious overall. We'll head back again soon to try out some of their unique pizza toppings on our next pizza.