Mama Mary's Pizza

In short, we received a salad with Gross black lettuce after hearing the kitchen staff joke about hiding it below the spinach. I ordered four pizzas, a salad, and mozzarella sticks. I arrived a few minutes early as a customer was leaving, so the kitchen staff didn't notice I had entered. They proceeded to talk about the salad they were making and said, "just hide it under the spinach and no one will see it". When I politely confronted them the person in charge said that romaine never looks very pretty and so they put the spinach on top to improve the presentation and assured me everything was ok with the salad. As soon as I or anyone else started eating the salad we noticed that ALL of the romaine at the bottom of the salad was black see photos. I can understand that as a small business you can't always use the 100% freshest ingredients, but to joke about and then serve someone entirely rotten lettuce is unacceptable. On top of this they confused which order was mine, so I waited an extra 15 minutes for my pizzas, only for the staff to realize the pizza was actually done on time and that my once hot pizzas were sitting on the shelf for 15 minutes and now no longer hot. We will not be back. Parking: The parking lot serves several businesses and parking was difficult.

I am from the Philadelphia area and know pizza. For the Midwest it was pretty good. I believe they are more of a 3.75 but they were also very friendly so I gave time a 4 star. I will be back. The only issue was the size of the medium pizza. It was more like a small.

I'm from New Jersey and have been wanting a taste from.home and I finally found it. Great food that taste like the east coast pizza and great customer service. Had a conversation about the food and New York while waiting on my food. Thank you. I found my pizza spot.

I ordered a small pizza close to closing time and the hamburger that was thrown on top looked like scrapings from the frying pan after you’ve overcooked a burger! Usually I’ve gotten great pizza from this restaurant, not close to closing and a young lady couldn’t bring herself to refund my money, she only gave me $3 off my next pizza and acted as if it hurt her to do that so I won’t be returning because the past couple of times I’ve ordered from There the food has been subpar!

I've had their food plenty of times, good stuff, that's why I keep ordering. Placed an order online like I always do. No issues. Drove over to pick up the order, only to find the location closed. While I realize there was weather that day, I would assume there was a way to turn off the order system so customers knew that the location was closed? Picked up frozen pizzas at the Aldi next door which WAS open. Was not the same.

Honest and humble people, great tasting local pizza. I have placed an order through call and went to pick up expecting to pay the price displayed online, but when I went in for pickup they said they have applied a coupon and gave me discount, even though they could have just charged for the full amount. That’s honesty rare to find. Pizza was good too, in the journey of seeing local pizzerias, found this, and this surely deserves its rating and reviews. Cheese was delicious and different from other pizzerias. Garden pizza was delicious! One of the best that I have tried in the recent times.

I'm from CT where mom and pop shops for pizza are on every corner. New York style crust cheese and old world pep is the way to go. The bigger the pie the better.Food: 5/5

Excellent New York Style pizza. Make sure you sign up for their rewards program if you plan on repeat business.Food: 5/5

This is by far the best pizza in Toledo or the Midwest for that matter!!! The crust , the sauce, the meat is so authentic I come once. Week for the pizza. But I tried the pasta it was amazing too

This place is great! Did you know they hand chop the chicken for your chicken subs and pizza. It is a real chicken breast diced by hand by some great people. Then male manager iet was great and personalable. He was honest and real. Everyone knows working food service dealing with jerk people all day can wear you done and he has a great personality and I will definitely we walking over to see them more ony lunch. This velocity chick loves this place. Can't wait to see you at pizzapalozza this weekend!