Judy's Pizzeria

I've been avoiding this place for the past 6 months. It just seemed off. December 27th went in for a cheese slice and was offered the remaining 6 slices in the display for $8 as it was about 5/6 minutes until closing. I shouldve said no. The crust is too thick and very dry, its cloying, the cheese was non existent and aged- not on purpose, barely any sauce on the slice. I ended up forcing myself through the cheese slice and throwing the other slices away. I refuse to go here again. It's not good pizza at all!

Sauce no taste, crust was chewy. I asked for double pepperoni and that certainly didn't happen. It's been years since I bought from there and now I remember why. I have had better tasting pizza from low budget competitors. Not going to spend $32.00 to my door again.

I am not one to complain and write reviews but I ordered from this place and got a really bad Lasagna. It was burnt ,watery and stuck to charred foil tray. On calling the owner to inform him he hung up on me. I called again and he just said "well don't order again". And hung up on me. I called again and when I told him that I was not happy with the food he yelled at me and said "I am tired of you people trying to get free food" I told him that I was not looking for free food and he continued to yell at me and called me a liar basically. I told him that I could send him a picture but he was not willing to listen and kept yelling at me. After he hung up I decided to post this on here showing the alleged "Six" layer Lasagna which in reality was one layer of tasteless overcooked watery "from frozen" mess of a meal. Please see the picture and try and avoid this restaurant unless you are a glutton for punishment,verbal abuse and really bad Lasagna.

Have been eating here for decades. I had moved away and decided to grab lunch for my mom and I as a treat. I ordered over the phone and was shocked to hear $13.75 each for 2 small panzerotti’s and $8.99 for a Greek salad. The salad didn’t have tomatoes and the lettuce was not fresh brown spots. The onions looked like they were cut a month ago and smelled really strong I think because they were old. We had bacon in the panzerotti’s and the bacon had a funny taste my stomach is still turning. Food went in the garbage and I will never order here again. It’s a shame as this place used to have really great food :

Had once before and enjoyed the pizza. Tried today and 1st was delayed then pizza arrived cold also ordered 2 chicken 2 meatball sandwiches with mushrooms and 2 with cheese. The sandwiches were so dry it hurt our teeth to eat. Meatballs were tiny and lacking and didn't see mushrooms or cheese. Was horrible if I'm honest. The chicken ones were also so dry and tough to eat the chicken was tiny flat and so dry. I've never had to leave a review like this before but skip the dishes app crapped out on me and felt I had to post it somewhere. I wouldn't even want replacement meal after that. Won't fall for that again. Just won't order

We used to order from this place and for a little while now their quality has gone way down not to mention very cheap on toppings for the money spent. For the last time we ordered pizza and bruschetta on Thursday evening Dec 30th. The bruschetta was absolutely disgusting I'm mean really bad and the pizza made me sick for two days due to unfresh ingredients. We used to be loyal customers however they have seem to not take pride in their food quality nor value us any longer as loyal customers to a local restaurant. That said we will never be going back or ordering from Judy's again. The worst $80.00 I ever spent complete RIP-OFF Infact McDonald's is Gourmet food compared to this place thanks for making me sick for two days and by the way wear a mask while you're making this dog food that you serve people. Not worth a penny do everyone a favor and close up shop. PS. STOP MAKING BRUSCHETTA YOU HAVE NO CLUE HOW TO MAKE IT. DISGUSTING.

We have ordered from Judy's Pizza many times in the past and the pizza has been quite good, HOWEVER we ordered pizza last night through Door Dash and quite simply it was the worst pizza we had ever had !! it was delivered cold and we cannot exactly fault Judy's for that, however the crust was like cardboard, the toppings were not very appealing or fresh, and there was barely any sauce on the pizza , it was a very dry pizza and and quite frankly it tasted like a grocery store frozen pizza that has been sitting in a fridge for a week after being cooked, very disappointing and we will NOT be ordering from this establishment again. We would have been better off throwing the money we spent on this over priced Pizza out of the window of our vehicle !! I had to give 1 star to submit this review, but honestly this is not deserving of a single star

Very dissapointing. Pizza was reminiscent of 90s frozen pizzas. The sauce tasted like it came out of a can, and the dough was very dense. Cheese was lacking and tasted like store bought pre shredded mozzarella. Overall, with 8 different pizza options with a 5 min distance, this is not one to come back to.

We ordered from uber eats today and I can’t believe how downhill this place has gone. We ordered 3 veal sandwiches. All which cost $9.00 each. They were made on stale baguette bread and there was one tiny piece of veal in each sandwich. I can’t believe they charge that much for 1/4 of a piece of a veal cutlet. The sauce is tangy and it was just terrible. I can’t believe the chef would even put a sandwich together like that and call it a meal. When you get a California sandwich for the same price you get a great portion of meat 3 layers of cutlet minimum and it’s made on a real fresh soft bun. Never again save your money and don’t come here.

Pizza and Wings arrived at room temperature . I asked for easy on the tomato sauce and they put way too much on my pizza . There was hardly any mozzarella cheese on my pizza. I felt like I was biting into a tomato sauce pizza. The wings were ok but were at room temperature They would have been good if they came to me warm and I don't use microwaves to heat them up. It was my first time ordering here so I can't compare to previous orders. I won't order here again unfortunately Not saying its bad pizza... just saying it's not for me.

Directions to Judy's Pizzeria with public transportation

---