Formaggio's Pie Shack

Hands down one of the best pizzas we have ever had. Let me preface with with the fact that this isn’t your “traditional” deep dish pizza nor is it something you want to get if you’re not literally obsessed with cheese. Now that said. Don’t think of going hear & leaving a bad review because they use too much cheese or it’s “not a real deep dish”. Do your research and make sure it’s something you’ll like before going there. Moving along. We drive over an hour and half to get this pizza & it’s worth every bit of hassle. The toppings, the sauce, side dipping sauces are all amazing. I highly recommend their garlic ranch & chipotle mayo for dipping. The nachos are a bit pricey as they usually are at most places. But here they are totally worth it. They are COVERED from corner to corner will toppings and cheese! They don’t hold back at all! Everything on their menu is great. But you have to experience the deep dish at least once!

Worth the drive!!! I had the stuffed deep dish pizza that was cooked to perfection, cheese browned on top and the crust great tasting while holding together the HUGE amount of cheese and toppings. The service was excellent and friendly. I live over an hour away and will be making trek again.

I just had their deep dish pizza for the first time and it was awesome. I had a personal size, made with bacon, ham and pineapple, with their home-made original sauce see the attached pictures - I did have a slice before taking these pictures. I loved how much toppings, cheese and sauce they used. I would definitely recommend this place to put on your list of places to try out. They also have a nice little dine-in area on the backside of the restaurant too.

I love the tiny back of the house experience. Service was awesome! Pizza was different and good. It's a ton of dough, toppings and cheese! A small was enough for 2. Came out to $27 with tip. Less than fast food and worth it!

The best pizza you will find in the area. Deep dish pizza will blow your mind and leave you beyond full. Pizzas are a tad pricey but well WELL worth it! Give it a try and be ready to be amazed. Great for parties and events. The deep dish pizzas aren't cut because it's best if you choose your own size of piece.

I ordered the 1lb deep dish pizza with chipotle mayo dip. It was very flavorful, great portion for the price and lots of cheese on top. The only thing I would ask for next time is more sauce.

So if you want a sauce from a canned, low grade sausage and kielbasa with very very low grade cheese that is like a rubber and pay $50 amazing this will be best restaurant/bar food. Otherwise it is not good in any sense. Not sure if this was one instance as we ordered on St Patrick's Day and due to unusual crowd they missed our order. but our deep dish pizza was more like dish of canned tomatoes sauce with 200grams of cheese ... Sad face as some pictures on google Reviews kept our hope very high.

This Treasure of a place has the thickest deep dish pizza that I ever had! I find the prices are reasonable especially for the quality of food that you get! I have definitely ordered from there more than once and I'm going to do it again every time I go through London what a great place!

The service at the take-out counter was excellent and speedy. The food looked exceptional and tasted even better. Probably one of the best pizza’s we’ve had. The garlic bread was amazing too, made with nice fresh buns and servings are large. We would’ve had enough with a three piece but didn’t realize how big the serving was. We’ve got some in the freezer now to look forward to on another day. We had a Greek salad as well and it, like everything else was fresh and tasty. Overall all of the food was excellent. The pizza had generous toppings, the salad as well with lots of cheese and veggies and the garlic bread was very tasty with lots of cheese. Great price too!

Wow, what a pizza!! Got the deeeeep dish pizza and it didn't disappoint. Fed 4 adults and we had leftovers. If you like cheese and quality ingredients, this is the place for you.