Ernie's Icebox

Pricey for what you get. Though I understand they're all handmade. Sandwiches are very hard to eat as they are so thick and the cookies frozen solid. Ice cream flavours are meh. Better options in the neighbourhood if you're looking for ice cream. That said, they are a novelty and certainly worth a try if you're in the area, but for our family it's a "been there, tried that" and I don't think we'll be repeat customers. Shop is spotlessly clean, and staff is very friendly and welcoming.

A little too sweet for my taste but if you like the traditional American-style sweetness level for desserts, you'll love this place. I agree with the other review that they are a little difficult to eat. If the cookie was more like a brownie, it would be softer and the ice cream wouldn't squish out all over. The shop is very cute and the staff are great.

Strawberry Rhubarb pie. Amazing. Perfect cookie to ice cream ratio. Wish I had more to eat. Fun pop up at Underpass Park Farmers Market. Best ice cream I've eaten all week

The flavours are so unique and I can't stop going back to try others. The ice cream sandwiches are always 10/10, my favourite being the blakforest with a melt in your mouth brownie sandwich. They also have handmade Italian sodas! I can't recommend this place enough. Lemon-blueberry cheesecake icecream sandwich pictured

Tasted good. I had a Black Forest Ice Cream Sandwich pictured. Feedback for owners: My wife’s PB&J ice cream sandwich was very light on the J, which was disappointing.

Tried their Earl Grey Honey Ice cream sandwich at their popup at a coffee shop and loved it! Will go to their actual shop to try more of their flavours!

Love all the unique flavours they have here. It’s a cute little place that you might miss if you didn’t know it was there. But really tasty ice cream sandwiches!

This is the best ice cream cake I have ever had! I cannot wait to go back and try the ice cream sandwiches!

Had the Birthday Cake ice cream sandwich myself and Key Lime Pie for my daughter. The sandwich/cookie part is to die for. Just spectacular! Everything made from scratch including the ice cream. Love seeing an ice cream sandwich establishment so close to home. What a dream!

Cute little ice-cream sandwich place. Staff is super friendly. Loved the vibes, packaging, and of course the ice-cream.

Directions to Ernie's Icebox with public transportation

---