ElMar's New York Pizza

This is the best pizza I have ever had here in Minnesota. The home made pesto is insanely good. The pepperoni is also awesome and not skimping on toppings at all. You get your money’s worth when you order pizza from them and you won’t be disappointed

My first time there and it won't be my last. The slices are huge and delicious. Cheesey and crispy. The staff was so helpful and kind. I also appreciated all of the slice options they had. They even had a white pizza like they make it in NJ. Pizza heaven.

If you haven't tried out this New York pizza place in Plymouth that you keep hearing about, you need to stop what you're doing, get out here, and grab a slice. Nicole and Mike make the best pies around! Go Rangers ;

Great tasting NY style pizza here. 45 min for a fresh pizza but by the slice is quick, tasty and heated up! Friendly and busy staff. They gave the kiddos some pizza dough to play with while we waited.