This week, I went to Dairy Island for the first time. The place is really cute with a lot to take in visually. That's always a plus for me. In addition to the menu over the register, be sure to note the one on the wall off to the left. Service was super friendly. If it's busy, it may take a bit to get your order, but it's worth the wait. My sister had raved about the hand-breaded mushrooms, so I tried those. They're absolutely amazing. The breading is fresh and light. Very delicious. I also grabbed a funnel cake, which was quite good. I definitely plan to go back to try out a few more things from the menu. Plus, they have 24 different flavors of twist cone and I want to sample several. This is the perfect place to stop for snacks on a hot summer day.
A tasty slice of Americana, with plenty of flavors of soft serve ice cream, a well rounded menu of appetizers, burgers, and other classic roadside dining options. Its got indoor and outdoor seating, friendly service, and is a great place to stop for a snack when you’re in the Mauston area. Id recommend the german chocolate ice cream, and the curd burger was also quite good.
Never judge a book by its over. This is def a hidden gem i wish i could take home with me. Something about the interior keeps drawing you in and no matter where you look there is something eye catching. I ended up following another review here, getting the sweet n spicy beef dog they were out of hotdogs at the time. Totally awesome from the beef, fresh veggies, and mouthwatering bread. My meal was made in a timely manner and served by a super chill older gentleman. I wish i could bring this place home w me.
I got their jumbo gyro. It was absolutely delicious. Everything we ordered was delicious. This will be my new little spot. I only work 2 mins away. Glad I finally tried it.
My first impression walking through the door was that it might be a cool, small town dive. TONS of soft serve flavors and the other menu items like deep fried foods. Not the most healthy, but heck it's called Dairy Island. We ordered jalapeno poppers cream cheese, deep fried pickle spears, curly fries, 2 strips of chicken and soft serve as we left. After we placed our order and sat waiting for our food we waited a reasonable amount of time. No worries there. I was curious about the establishments reviews, so I Googled it. Wow, the reviews for this place are concerning. SO many poor reviews for cleanliness. I then saw everything through a different light. I was now fearful of my foods arrival. What kind of mysterious, potentially contaminated, journey did our food endure before ending up at our table? The guy at the register that took our order was friendly and seemed clean enough. But then we saw the cook walk out. Now mind you, we were overall pretty skeptical at this point because we had just read numerous pretty terrible reviews. The cook was wearing pajama pants? Maybe? An interesting graphic tee? I would say that he definitely could have looked cleaner. I think we would have enjoyed our food more if we hadn't seen him. Might I suggest a uniform? The food was mediocre. Not bad. It was cheap, so we got what we paid for. We haven't gotten sick yet...so fingers crossed . The soft serve was tasty, however the reviews really ruined it for me. I won't be back. This place sheds a whole new light on "fine dining". Which is what I will be seeking from here on out. Best of luck to you. If you have a good experience. Definitely leave a review! This place needs them.
Came here a few months back with family and tried the pistachio flavored ice cream. Great stuff!!
Small town ice cream shop with good food, if you like hot dogs and peppers you will need to try the Chicago dog! The owner is from Chicago and knows how to do it right!
Just got ice creme it was like soup!Food: 1/5
Great place to eat and a variety of foods to choose from.Food: 5/5
Great stop along route 12 for a quick bite!Food: 5/5
